The CEO of Wells Fargo & Co. should be forced to resign and he should be thankful he simply lost his job and not his liberty.
Tim Sloan, at the helm of one of the world’s largest banking institutions for more than two years, has seemed at best casual in responding to bank regulators who have been tasked to investigate a succession of bad acts at the San Francisco-based institution. Despite some dramatic slap-around — a consent order from the Federal Reserve that restricts the bank’s growth was issued after the bank failed to correct deficiencies that had been previously identified, and a $1 billion fine was levied by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — it almost seemed like business as usual.
Until the next scandal. And it has come.
Wells Fargo now is paying compensation to hundreds of homeowners who were pushed into foreclosure after they were denied mortgage modifications for which they qualified. The modifications could have allowed the customers the opportunity to hold onto their homes. It didn’t happen just a couple of times. The bank acknowledges that in nearly 900 cases since 2010, mortgage modifications were wrongly denied and 545 homes actually were lost to foreclosure.
The institution also had opened millions of bogus savings, checking and credit card accounts customers didn’t want, earning the company a fine of $185 million; it had wrongly repossessed thousands of cars when owners didn’t pay for insurance policies they didn’t want; and then there was the role it played in the burst housing bubble that led to the Great Recession.
And in a stunning display of tone-deafness, the bank recently announced that it would cut 26,000 jobs — even though it expected to boost its profits $3.7 billion for 2018.
The National Consumer Law Center has alleged that Wells Fargo has a pattern of failing to maintain its systems, finding problems when they occurred, then masking their problems when they did finally find them.
While it is true the bank’s sins were committed before Mr. Sloan’s rise to CEO in mid-October 2016, they happened while this longtime insider was operating as chief financial officer and chief administrative officer. If he didn’t commit the sins himself, he knew about them. And if he didn’t know about them, he should have.
With 31 years of tenure, he’s been around long enough to know that substantive and highly visible change and amends were needed to make Wells Fargo right. Failing to appreciate the mistakes of yesterday amounts to another mistake today.
With Democrats winning control of the U.S. House and Rep. Maxine Waters, a vocal critic of Wells Fargo, expected to chair the House Financial Services Committee, Mr. Sloan is considered likely to be called to testify. This kind of scrutiny is, at best, bad publicity not needed by one of America’s Big Four banks.
What has happened because of the misdeeds of Wells Fargo has had tragic consequences for many Americans and it has been, at least in the colloquial sense, criminal. Whether it is legal criminally is for the U.S. Justice Department to discern and such inquiries should be made. Penalties that have been levied thus far hurt only the stakeholders in the business. The pain should be felt by those who dealt the blows.
And, at the close of business, there’s a reason Mr. Sloan earned $17.4 million in 2017 (a base salary of $2.4 million plus a $15 million bonus.) He ultimately is responsible. He should go home to his $5-million-plus mansion in California and be glad there aren’t bars are the doors. For now.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.