If it were funny, this circular story would sounds like a “Who’s on First?” routine.
But it wasn’t funny.
Rebecca Johns, 63, was dealing with the death of her 91-year-old mom and the settlement of the estate plus the usual chores of everyday life when PNC Bank mucked it up so badly the Mercer County woman had to hire an attorney.
Ms. Johns’ mom had rented a safe deposit box at a PNC Bank branch in Greenville, Mercer County, to store her last will and testament. When her mom died on Aug. 7, PNC Bank representatives refused to open the safe deposit box.
To get access to the box, PNC said, she needed the will. To get the will, she needed access to the box.
It wasn’t enough that Ms. Johns was her mom’s primary caretaker. Or that she held her power of attorney. Or that she had a copy of her mom’s will, which named her as the estate executor. Or that she had the death certificate, verifying her mom’s passing.
The bank wouldn’t let Ms. Johns into the box. The bank wouldn’t even allow one of its own bank employees to retrieve the will.
Rather, PNC Bank’s legal department required Ms. Johns to go to court to seek official appointment as “personal representative” of her mother’s estate before allowing access. But — and this is a big “but” — under Pennsylvania law, a person cannot be appointed by a court as the personal representative of an estate without having the decedent’s original copy of the person’s last will and testament. Once again, Ms. Johns needed access to the box.
This circus ride was inconvenient and costly.
And it was nonsense because state law allows a next of kin to enter a safe deposit box after the death of a loved one for the limited purpose of obtaining an original will as well as a cemetery deed. “I am astonished something like this could go so far when it seems so simple,” said Aubrey Glover, a trusts and estates lawyer at Brenlove & Fuller law firm in Bridgeville. She also serves as secretary of the Allegheny County Bar Association’s probate council.
After some weeks of wrangling, PNC Bank shifted course and permitted Ms. Johns access to the safe deposit box and bank officials said policies were being reviewed. And a confidential settlement was made with Ms. Johns, as well.
The law may be the law but that doesn’t mean bank employees will understand the law.
While it may be common for people to protect their important papers by storing them in a safe deposit box, this situation should serve as a cautionary tale: File the original copy of your will with your attorney’s office or buy a fireproof safe and keep it in your home.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.