A Mercer County woman was permitted to open her deceased mother’s safe deposit box at 9 a.m. Tuesday, more than a month after officials at PNC Bank had denied her access to the box.

In addition, a PNC Bank official said the Pittsburgh bank is reviewing its policies on will searches involving its storage products.

Rebecca Johns filed suit against the Pittsburgh bank in mid-September, asking a Common Pleas judge to force representatives at a PNC branch in Greenville, Mercer County, to open the box owned by her mother, Nila Beaver, who died Aug. 7 at the age of 91.

The original copy of Ms. Beaver’s last will and testament was believed to have been in the box. Ms. Johns needed the original document in order to have a court appoint her as the personal representative of her mother’s estate, but the bank wanted proof she had been appointed to that role by the court before allowing her access.

Advertise with us

After the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported on the situation, PNC changed its position and made arrangements for Ms. Johns to access the safe deposit box on the first day after the Columbus Day bank holiday.

“We have taken steps to resolve the matter with the customer,” Amy Vargo, vice president of media for PNC Bank, said Tuesday.

“We continuously seek to refine our policies and procedures to ensure the best possible customer experience, and we are revisiting our policies related to will searches to ensure that we provide appropriate access to the contents of safe deposit and express storage boxes,” she said.

“I feel very relieved now,” Ms. Johns, 63, said after retrieving the original copy of her mother’s will. “Now I can move forward with everything that needs to be taken care of. I feel like a big weight has been lifted.”

Ms. Johns said she is satisfied now that she has the will, which names her as the executor of the estate. “I just want to move forward and put this behind us,” she said.

Advertise with us

Her attorney, Jason Dibble of the Wallace and Dibble law firm in Mercer County, said he is happy with the confidential settlement made with PNC Bank, although it will prevent him and his client from discussing its details.

A hearing had been scheduled for Nov. 28 in the Court of Common Pleas of Mercer County, Pennsylvania Orphans’ Court Division. Ms. Johns will ask that the case against PNC Bank be dismissed.

“We are happy with the resolution,” Mr. Dibble said. “But we are not happy with the means we were required to pursue to obtain a resolution.”

Pennsylvania law permits the next of kin to enter a safe deposit box after the death of a loved one for the limited purpose of withdrawing the original will or cemetery deed.

State law also allows a bank employee to retrieve the original last will and testament from a safe deposit box to allow a person to be appointed by the court as the estate’s personal representative.

Advertise with us

The chief of consumer services at the Pennsylvania Department of Banking said in a statement that the state agency does not get many cases like this one.

In an email, he speculated that the bank might have been protecting itself in case there are other heirs. If Ms. Johns were allowed to enter the safe deposit box and take the contents, “The bank would be held responsible should another heir appear to request entry.”

Ms. Johns has two siblings, a younger and an older sister who both live in Seattle. Their mother had given Ms. Johns power of attorney to handle her affairs.

Ms. Johns also had provided the bank with a copy of their mother’s will, which named her as executor. She needed the original version that was in the safe deposit box to present to the court.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.