It really is time for the Pittsburgh Penguins to deliver more than promises on the former Civic Arena site. Frustration with the lack of development bubbled up last week and led to a lunch meeting Tuesday between Mayor Bill Peduto and Pens CEO David Morehouse. Afterward, Mr. Peduto said he soon hopes to have a deal that puts development on the rails and penalizes the team for further delays.
That would be the ideal outcome. While Mr. Peduto, Urban Redevelopment Authority member Jim Ferlo and Sports & Exhibition Authority member James Ellenbogen had every right last week to be impatient about the pace of progress, the Pens have invested millions of dollars in the project so far and have every reason to want to bring it to a successful conclusion. What team wouldn’t want to claim ownership of a vibrant mixed-use site next door to home ice in one of the most visible parts of one of America’s most dynamic cities?
Criticism stings, especially when it is delivered by the ever-blunt Mr. Ferlo, but Mr. Morehouse was out of line to get defensive last week. This is the public’s land; the Pens merely have been awarded the privilege of developing it. As stewards of the property, URA and SEA members and other public officials have a duty to speak out if they become concerned about the pace of development or other problems at the 28-acre site.
The Penguins repeatedly have purchased extensions to the development timetable. Some of the delay, such as that caused by U.S. Steel’s decision in 2015 to back out of a headquarters project there, was not the team’s fault. But the Pens haven’t broken any speed records with the residential component or other aspects of the development, either.
Demolition of the arena was completed about five years ago, and the site has been nothing but a parking lot since the debris was hauled away. Development will bolster the tax base and create new working, dining and living options. It also will re-establish connections between the Lower Hill and Downtown that were lost when the arena was constructed in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
After his lunch Tuesday, Mr. Peduto said he’s working on a deal that spells out development deadlines and imposes penalties for missing them. Any deal must be good for the taxpayers. If the Pens continue to struggle, Mr. Peduto, Mr. Ferlo and Mr. Ellenbogen should continue to speak up.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.