The Pittsburgh Steelers may have hoped to avoid controversy while waiting in the tunnel during the playing of the national anthem Sunday in Chicago, but the decision to stay off the field itself was viewed as a sign of disrespect for the flag. Now, some angry fans have turned their backs on the black and gold. It goes to show how raw emotions are around the issue of race in America — and how sad it is to let professional football become a battleground in this conflict.
The National Football League, its brand already slipping because of an epidemic of traumatic brain injury among professional and amateur football players, has a crisis on its hands. The Steelers’ example may have been highly publicized, with only lineman Alejandro Villanueva, a former Army Ranger who served in Afghanistan, visible during the anthem, hand over his heart as he stood at the entrance of the tunnel. But variations on the theme occurred league-wide Sunday, with some players kneeling for the anthem while others stood, often with their arms locked together. Players from the Seattle Seahawks and Tennessee Titans also stayed off the field during the anthem.
How sad. Sports is a great unifying force. Now it’s become one more source of divisiveness?
The NFL and its team need to respect their fans, most of whom stand for the anthem and expect the players to do so, too. The anthem tells the story of American resilience, a resilience still in demand today as the nation struggles with various problems ... including race relations. Standing for the anthem does not make one party to a conspiracy to paper over the nation’s flaws.
But sitting it out is widely considered to be defiant. At the very least, it is bad manners for players to go out of their way to show disrespect for something so many other people hold dear. Those who kneel during the anthem are making a statement that is open to misinterpretation — what some see as using a spotlight to call out racial injustice, others see as dishonoring the nation’s military.
Last season, Colin Kaepernick launched the controversy by first sitting and later kneeling during the anthem when he was a quarterback with the San Francisco 49ers — something he did to draw attention to social injustice and the deaths of African-Americans at the hands of police. Now a free agent, Mr. Kaepernick at the moment plays for no one, perhaps because he’s considered a PR liability.
Other players on various teams have continued taking the knee, however, prompting President Donald Trump to suggest during a rally Friday in Alabama, in his usual colorful language, that NFL teams fire players who refuse to stand for the anthem. He should not have stirred the pot. Athletes, who responded with angry tweets, were wrong to let Mr. Trump bait them. The NFL leadership and many team owners generally stood by their players.
Unable to reach a consensus on what to do during the anthem at Sunday’s game against the Bears in Chicago, or how to respond to Mr. Trump’s comments and the ensuing Twitter storm, the Steelers decided to wait in the tunnel until the singing ended. They may have hoped to stay out of the controversy in this way. “We did not want to appear divided on the sideline with some standing and some kneeling or sitting,” quarterback Ben Roethlisberger said on his website Monday. But the plan backfired. Mr. Roethlisberger’s hometown of Findlay, Ohio — officially known as “Flag City, USA” — must not be proud of its native son.
Coach Mike Tomlin said he went along with the players’ collective decision. It turns out to have been a bad call. The Steelers’ management will need to speak clearly to regain the trust of its many fans.
Some fans, reading the players’ behavior as disrespect, have burned Steelers gear or otherwise forsaken the black and gold. But Mr. Villanueva’s popularity got a bump because he stood apart from his team. Mr. Tomlin has justifiably been criticized for leaving the impression that he was disappointed in Mr. Villanueva’s act, saying that was “looking for 100 percent participation.”
A person should never be criticized for honoring his nation’s flag, although Mr. Villanueva said Monday that he didn’t mean to end up at the front of the tunnel by himself.
On Monday, Mr. Roethlisberger said he regretted the decision to remain off the field. He and defensive end Cam Heyward said the team would be on the field for the anthem this Sunday, when the Steelers face the Ravens in Baltimore.
Which raises the question: What will happen around the NFL this coming Sunday and how will the league respond to it? The NFL official operations manual calls for players to stand on the sideline respectfully as the anthem is played. The NFL should enforce its own policy if it wants fans to respect calls on the field, too.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.