The controversial No Child Left Behind Act that was signed into law by President George W. Bush in 2002 has been replaced by a new piece of legislation. The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) revises many of the policies in the previous law.

What did the nation learn from the experience of No Child Left Behind? We saw that stronger federal oversight of public education doesn’t work well, since education policy is set primarily at the state and local levels. We learned that heavy accountability for math and English scores may lead school districts to cut class time for other subjects, such as history, music, art and languages. Students unfortunately received a narrower, rather than a broader, education under the law.

We also learned that setting arbitrary standards for every school to meet can punish schools and teachers for conditions beyond their control. Those standards, called Adequate Yearly Progress under No Child Left Behind, led many schools to be labeled as failing. Florida became famous for labeling all of its public schools with letter grades from A to F, grades which were based on questionable data and standards.

Above all, what the nation learned is that we relied far too much on standardized testing to measure the progress of individual students and their schools.  The number of school days spent on practice testing and actual testing skyrocketed, squeezing out other subject matter. Researchers can verify that standardized tests are not a complete measure of a student’s progress, and many bright children simply don’t test well.

Advertise with us

The pressure for good test results was so great that 11 educators were convicted in 2015 of altering students’ scores in Atlanta Public Schools. The cheating was widespread, involving a majority of the schools in the district and nearly 180 people. Several of the convicted educators served prison time.

However, NCLB’s goal — universal proficiency — was laudable. It’s still laudable. School districts must be held accountable for increasing student proficiency in key subjects, even if NCLB was too flawed to achieve its goals.

Last week the Pennsylvania Department of Education submitted its plan under the new federal law. The plan still requires standardized tests in English, math and science, but they will be shorter than before. As under NCLB, the new school report card will consider factors other than overall test scores in measuring a school’s success, such as  attendance rates. It also will consider new factors, such as enrollment in Advanced Placement courses. Learning from the past and fashioning broader measures of student, school and district achievement represent a step forward.

Pennsylvania still has one of the most inequitable public school systems in the country, with dangerously low state funding and unfair distribution of that funding. ESSA does not address those major concerns, and it will take political courage in Harrisburg to face up to them.