The announcement from the Senate Monday that it is dropping for the time being the effort to “repeal and replace” the Affordable Care Act is a relief to many consumers and provides an opportunity for Americans — both those who support and those who oppose Obamacare — to reset the discussion on health care.

The Senate Republicans have a reasonably comfortable advantage of 52 seats to 48, which should have made it possible for Majority Leader Mitch McConnell to stitch together a vote to repeal and replace the ACA. So far, the ACA is seen by most Americans as Barack Obama’s signature achievement as president, part of the reason the Republicans wanted to get rid of it.

But the Senate Republicans, led by Mr. McConnell, made some significant errors in crafting the replacement legislation, the Better Care Reconciliation Act of 2017. Thirteen male senators, many with white hair, drew up the proposed legislation, pretty much in secret. That especially annoyed female Republican senators, as well as other senators, Republicans and Democrats, who were not included in the drafting process.

It just didn’t make sense to exclude 87 senators from the preparation of a bill whose contents would eventually touch virtually all of the American population, a major mistake on the part of Mr. McConnell. It was extraordinary anyway that he would be leading the attack on a bill that would have denied Medicaid to thousands of voters in his state, Kentucky, many of whom are poor and dependent on Medicaid for health care.

Advertise with us

The proposed bill also ran headlong into another schism among Republican senators, between those whose states’ populations are dependent on government health care spending and those who are deficit hawks. The latter insist on cutting the national debt, now soaring toward $20 trillion, by reducing budget deficits that are partly generated by health care spending. This group considered the Republican alternative to the ACA insufficiently parsimonious.

The announcement by Sens. Jerry Moran of Kansas and Mike Lee of Utah Monday that they would not vote for the Republican measure marked its demise. There was talk of a Republican move to repeal the ACA anyway, without an acceptable replacement on deck, but that was not an approach that senators from states with medically vulnerable citizens could subscribe to.

Americans in general likely would be pleased to have at least the rest of the summer free of the threat of having their health care changed or made unaffordable by a political community in Washington that acts as though it doesn’t care about them. Health care is far too important to be used by politicians as a political beach volleyball.

Still, Obamacare and the health care system are far from perfect. In some places, Obamacare is at risk of flopping because of a lack of insurers and increasing premiums. There also is the matter of soaring drug costs nationwide and additional tools needed to fight the opioid epidemic. The conversation about health care is not — cannot — be over.