The disappearance of Amelia Earhart somewhere over the Pacific on July 2, 1937, is like the loose tooth of American history — every generation feels compelled to nudge it a little. Two decades into the 21st century, we’re still wondering what happened 80 years ago when the most famous woman in the world at that time attempted to circle the globe.

What we know for sure is that after taking off from New Guinea with navigator Fred Noonan in a Lockheed Electra, Earhart set a course for Howland Island in the Pacific. At one point she radioed the U.S. Coast Guard cutter Itasca that she was low on fuel and far from her destination. Then radio silence. What followed was the most extensive and expensive search in U.S. history up until that point, but neither wreckage of the plane nor the bodies of Earhart and Noonan were ever found. Crashing into the sea after running out of fuel was an unglamorous end to a very glamorous adventure.

But a funny thing happened as the Earhart story made the rounds. Alternative theories began to proliferate that involved the Electra crashing near an atoll or on a deserted island, giving Earhart and Noonan a fighting chance to survive. A skeleton discovered on one such island matched Earhart’s height and ethnicity but isn’t proof that it is her. All of the theories are variations of the premise she survived the crash but died a castaway somewhere.

Now there is a newer, far sexier theory of what happened. According to the producers of a new documentary premiering Sunday on the History Channel, a grainy photograph taken at the Jaluit Atoll in the Marshall Islands allegedly shows Earhart and Noonan alive on a dock near a Japanese ship called the Koshu. The photo is from the U.S. National Archives and was taken around the time Earhart disappeared by an American spy believed to be doing reconnaissance on the Japanese.

Advertise with us

The photo shows a woman alleged to be Earhart watching a plane being towed by the Koshu. Also standing on the dock is a man believed to be Noonan. Some are hailing the photo as proof that Earhart survived but was taken into custody by the Japanese under suspicion that she was a spy. The theory is that she died in detention. The Japanese didn’t want to spark an international incident by admitting they had her.

Many historians are skeptical of the theory, but it is compelling to those who want a more meaningful end for Earhart and Noonan than simply running out of gas over the Pacific. Until we find the actual wreckage of the Electra, we’ll never know for sure. The fact is, there are some stories that will never have the closure we crave. The disappearance of Amelia Earhart may be one of them.