The long-term fate of the Kurds, at least 30 million in number across the Middle East, currently America’s allies in fighting the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, is a question that the administration of President Donald J. Trump should be contemplating.
The Kurds, mostly Sunni Muslims, want a state of their own. They currently have the framework of one in northern Iraq, carved during war out of what used to be Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. They have armed forces, fighting relatively effectively in Iraq, around Mosul, and in Syria, around Raqqa, the fast-fading IS ex-capital. They have a militia, part of the Democratic Party of Kurdistan, at least capable of acts of terrorism, in Iran.
One Kurdish organization, the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, the PKK, has been active in Turkey for years, mostly carrying out acts of terrorism. An estimated 20 percent of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Turkey is made up of ethnic Kurds.
The United States, impressed by Kurdish forces’ fighting capacity and having protected them in Iraq starting with the first Gulf War, has provided them with a lot of arms, some of them sophisticated, to be used in principle in Iraq and in Syria against the Islamic State. The question then becomes what the Kurdish forces do with these arms after they have helped “liberate” Mosul and Raqqa from IS forces, assuming that is eventually achieved.
It would be dangerously naive for the United States to imagine that they will then disarm, hand the arms back to us, and go back to northern Iraq to work in the oil industry and farm. The Kurds also tend to fight among themselves, divided into clans such as the Talabanis and the Barzanis, which are also in principle separate from the PKK, the Kurdish group that most troubles the Turks.
For the Kurds to have their state, Iran, Iraq, Syria and Turkey would each have to agree to give up a piece of their territory to Kurdish rule. Iraq basically had no choice, given the American invasion in 2003. Syria, after the dust settles from its civil war, probably will have no choice either, with U.S.-equipped Kurdish forces installed on its territory. Iran will not accept any role for the Democratic Party of Kurdistan in that country, suspecting, even worse from Tehran’s point of view, American support of it.
Turkey, a fellow member of NATO with the United States, has pursued different policies toward the Kurds over the years. It has sometimes tried to make them feel more comfortable within Turkey. It has also cracked down on them sharply when Kurdish resistance to overall Turkish rule became too violent or too vociferous. The idea of American-armed Kurdish forces operating in nearby parts of Syria gives the Turks a real case of nerves, and easily provokes military action on their part.
For the moment, the United States is concentrating on putting the IS out of business in Iraq and in Syria. But Washington needs to think long and hard about what it is going to do with the Kurds after the battles of Mosul and Raqqa are over. Pushing the Kurds back into Iraq is probably the best bet, although that would be to facilitate more than a de facto breakup of the Iraqi state. It would constitute nation-building and a redrawing of Middle Eastern borders, undercutting the U.S.-supported regime in Baghdad — very serious business for the United States to undertake.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.