With the unexpected resignation of its president, Subra Suresh, Carnegie Mellon University is at a crossroads the likes of which Pittsburghers aren’t used to seeing. CMU is the world-renowned institution where the robots move with seamless precision, the thespians always remember their lines and some of the cars on campus are smart enough to drive themselves.
Mr. Suresh’s resignation after just four years is a sign that CMU isn’t humming on all cylinders after all. Until now, the average tenure of a CMU president was about 14 years, so Mr. Suresh’s departure is an unsettling development that warrants a candid explanation. In a letter, Mr. Suresh said only that he and his wife, Mary, believe CMU needs somebody else at the helm to implement long-term plans and “make that extended commitment to generating resources and guiding the university toward reaching these objectives.” If he has another job lined up, he didn’t say. Jim Rohr, chairman of the board of trustees, offered the customary niceties about Mr. Suresh’s service but provided no insight into what happened there.
All of Pittsburgh should be concerned.
An expert in engineering and materials science who graduated high school at 15, wrapped up his doctorate at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in two years and held faculty appointments at prestigious universities, Mr. Suresh is brilliant by anyone’s standards. Director of the National Science Foundation before joining CMU, he arrived in Pittsburgh with management experience. The job of university president, however, requires more than smarts and management ability.
The president also needs to be a tireless fundraiser and an engaging politician who is equally comfortable addressing student groups, faculty, corporate executives, philanthropists and elected officials at all levels of government. Was Mr. Suresh not a good fit for all of these roles? Did the trustees let him down in some way?
The trustees must take stock of these issues to prevent another failure, for Mr. Suresh’s hasty exodus can only be described as such. He announced his resignation Thursday, and it takes effect June 30. Mr. Suresh’s predecessor, Jared Cohon, was president for 16 years and gave three years’ notice before leaving the position.
The CMU president arguably matters more to Pittsburgh than most university leaders mean to their communities. The city’s image and destiny are linked with the university’s. So much that is progressive, cool and smart about Pittsburgh derives from the labs and classrooms at CMU. Uber would not have come to Pittsburgh, and Ford have followed Uber, if CMU hadn’t already been blazing a path forward with self-driving vehicles.
CMU cannot afford to have another leadership gaffe. Universities can go backward, even if they have a solid reputation and reason to believe that good teaching and research will go on no matter who is in charge. CMU’s prestige after all is relatively recent — it was Carnegie Tech until the 1960s — and its $1.7 billion endowment is much smaller than those of peer institutions such as Stanford and MIT.
Stable, capable leadership has been a major factor in CMU’s meteoric rise and must be restored as quickly as possible. Unlike cars, great universities — and the cities they call home — cannot be taught to drive themselves.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.