The state Supreme Court’s decision Monday allowing Pittsburgh police officers to live outside the city is a disappointment to everyone except the men and women in blue who are intent on exercising their new right. We join Mayor Bill Peduto in hoping there won’t be many of them.
The 6-0 Supreme Court ruling ended a long legal battle. Now, officers have the right to live within 25 air miles of the City-County Building, Downtown.
Mr. Peduto had one especially good reason to oppose the police union’s effort to end the long-standing residency requirement. He wants officers to feel invested in the neighborhoods they’re paid to protect, especially as he continues efforts to improve police-community relations. Residents also want police officers to be embedded in the community fabric; in a 2013 referendum, they overwhelmingly voted to keep the residency requirement for officers and other city workers in place.
Among the many other arguments for wanting officers to live in the city, one is logistical. When you need officers in a hurry, they need to be nearby. If they are to be permitted to decamp to the suburbs, rush-hour drive time to the station house, not 25 air miles from Downtown, seems a more sensible determinate for how far away they may live.
The police bureau’s annual report to the public for 2015, the most recent available online, shows that some of the city’s lowest crime rates are in the southern and western neighborhoods where officers make their homes. The presence of police officers deters others from committing crimes. Neighborhoods that lose police officer households could see an erosion in public safety, with attendant declines in the quality of neighborhood public schools. Neither the city nor the schools can afford the additional hollowing out that would come with the loss of more middle-class taxpayers to the suburbs.
We aren’t the only ones to realize this. Former Chicago Mayor Richard Daley once warned that the city would lose its middle class by lifting the residency requirement for city workers. His successor, Rahm Emanuel, reportedly flirted with the idea of backing off of the requirement but in the end decided to keep it, saying city workers are “anchors” who coach youth sports and otherwise serve as civic leaders.
The potential impact on police-community relations is a frequent concern among cities that have fought to keep officers living within their borders. The fear is that officers who parachute into the city from their suburban homes each day will be less in tune with, and more hostile toward, those they serve and protect. In other words, how will white officers from white suburbs behave in predominantly black city neighborhoods?
In Pittsburgh, the question is worth considering. Only about 13 percent of the force is black, while 26 percent of the city’s population is black. From 1997 to 2002, the police bureau was under federal monitoring because of civil rights complaints. There’s a reason Mr. Peduto wants to strengthen police-community relations.
The residency requirement was an odd battle for the police union to fight, even if some of its members want to explore better schools or living options outside the city. If officers leave en masse, the union, already locked in various battles with the administration, will lose all political clout. Other unions representing city workers might want to think long and hard about challenging the residency requirement, too.
The city should track the number of officers who leave the city and the number of new hires who choose not to locate here. It also should track crime rates and other quality-of-life metrics in southern and western neighborhoods to determine whether any loss of police officer households affects the vitality of those communities. These data should be included in the police bureau’s annual report to the public so that the impact of the Supreme Court’s ruling is clear and the city can consider the possible need for residency incentives in the future.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.