As a recent report from the Council of the Great City Schools showed, the Pittsburgh Public Schools are at a crossroads. Achievement rates have been stagnant for a decade, the district makes inadequate use of data to inform its work, the curriculum is disjointed, and its system for identifying the best teachers and principals is flawed.
There are concerns beyond those cited in the report, however, and chief among them is the school board’s occasional lapse of judgment. The board undertook a flawed search for a new superintendent, then stood by its chosen candidate, Anthony Hamlet, after concerns arose about embellishments and plagiarism on his resume.
The district cannot afford to tread water any longer or make additional gaffes. Academic stagnation will produce more enrollment declines, which will only compound the district’s problems and threaten the city’s vitality.
Voters should have a sense of urgency in mind when they go to the polls May 16 to elect school directors in Districts 3 (taking in parts of the Hill District and eastern neighborhoods), 5 (some southern and eastern neighborhoods) and 9 (some northern and western neighborhoods). They should elect candidates willing to ask tough questions and take unpopular positions, even if that means standing against the board majority.
In District 3, the Post-Gazette endorses Sala Udin, a longtime activist from the Hill District and former city councilman. He is running against James Myers Jr., director of community affairs and business development at Urban Innovation21, a Hill District-based community improvement and development organization. The seat is open because school board member Thomas Sumpter decided not to seek re-election.
Mr. Udin, 74, and Mr. Myers, 37, are running as Democrats. No Republican candidate is on the ballot, meaning the winning Democrat likely will cruise to victory in the fall.
Mr. Udin gets it. He described the schools as being “in a crisis.” He understands the need to raise achievement levels and raise graduation rates, noting dropping out “can be a death sentence” in some neighborhoods. He bemoaned the district’s “culture of low expectations” and demanded higher standards.
Mr. Myers is polished, enthusiastic and smart. The city schools should be proud to count him among their alumni, and he is grateful for the teachers who guided him to graduation. He is the face of 21st-century Pittsburgh.
Instead of sharing his opponent’s angst about the state of the schools, however, Mr. Myers spoke of promoting the district’s successes. “It’s not all bad,” he said. While the district has pockets of excellence — and should promote them — the laser focus must be on righting the ship.
Mr. Udin has demonstrated his willingness to take a difficult stand and say the unpopular thing. He criticized the board for using a search firm unqualified for recruiting a school superintendent and opposed the selection of Mr. Hamlet because he had never run a district of any size before.
Later, Mr. Udin said, he met with Mr. Hamlet and told him, “I need for you to be successful.” He said he told Mr. Hamlet that he was willing to work with him, not as a “silent partner” but “a critical partner.” That is the kind of voice the board needs, and Mr. Udin’s gravitas will add stability to the district.
In District 5, one-term incumbent Terry Kennedy, 55, is seeking re-election against Ghadah Makoshi, 40. Both are from Squirrel Hill, and both cross-filed, meaning the two could face each other again in the fall. The Post-Gazette endorses Ms. Kennedy, who had a long record of involvement in the school district as a parent before joining the board and, like Mr. Udin, has proven a willingness to take difficult positions.
Ms. Kennedy voted for the flawed superintendent search and was part of the unanimous decision to hire Mr. Hamlet. Once problems with his resume surfaced, however, she was one of two board members who made an unsuccessful bid to rescind his offer of employment. Although she said Mr. Hamlet has demonstrated leadership since then, she described the resume controversy as a poor example for students and at odds with the high standards she wants the district to uphold.
Ms. Makoshi, who owns a baby equipment rental company, said she experienced the district’s shortcomings firsthand when she was unable to find a school with a full-time nurse. Her 8-year-son is a transplant recipient.
She wants to put more nurses and librarians in schools, lower class sizes, allow students more opportunities to be active during the day, and expand exposure to art, music and career and technical education. While these are good ideas, she presented no compelling reason for unseating Ms. Kennedy.
The Post-Gazette makes no endorsement in District 9, where one-term incumbent Carolyn Klug, 58, a former teacher from Brighton Heights, is running against Veronica Edwards, 67, a former district administrator from Windgap. Ms. Klug is running only on the Democratic ticket, while Ms. Edwards has cross-filed, setting up a possible rematch between the two in the fall.
Ms. Klug stood by Mr. Hamlet during the resume flap, a position we cannot endorse. Ms. Edwards did not offer a strong alternative to Ms. Klug.
In District 7, a race between incumbent Cynthia Falls and Conrad Burns fizzled when the latter dropped out of the race and stopped campaigning, even though it was too late to remove his name from the ballot. In District 1, incumbent Sylvia Wilson is running unopposed. Given the district’s urgent need for improvement, it is a shame to let any incumbent sail to another term.
Sala Udin and Terry Kennedy are the best choices in this year’s contested school board races, and they receive the Post-Gazette’s endorsement.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.