Mayor Bill Peduto and the police brass should have been embarrassed last year when a national report listed Pittsburgh as one of three cities in the study that hadn’t put their policies on officer body cameras in the public domain. But they weren’t chastened. Asked by the media to release the policy, the bureau declined.
“Right now, we’re under a policy where we don’t do that with our policies,” Cmdr. Ed Trapp said at the time.
How progressive. The bureau’s illogical recalcitrance came to the fore again last week when city officials declined to release two policies that could shed light on how an officer at the center of a misconduct complaint might have better handled a call about a suicidal woman.
The policies concerned standards of conduct and the handling of calls involving mental illness. Instead of immediately turning over the information, as it should have done, the bureau told the Post-Gazette to file a right-to-know request so the law department could vet the policies to make sure providing them wouldn’t divulge police strategies and tactics, giving criminals an edge.
It’s difficult to see how releasing information about the police bureau’s standards of conduct would aid and abet the criminal element. It’s highly unlikely that most policies contain anything that would compromise police work.
Here’s what Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the independent Citizen Police Review Board, said last year about the city’s refusal to provide the body camera policy: “It’s ridiculous. Those policies and procedures provide administrative guidance. There’s no strategic advantage to knowing what’s in those orders. It’s not going to defeat a law enforcement action. It’s basic guidance for police officers in Pittsburgh.”
Even so, the city was supposed to be putting together a public version of its police manual. “Currently, the police bureau’s policy manual is intermingled with its procedural manual — police protocol has long been not to release the manuals due to fears that releasing police procedures would jeopardize officer safety,” mayoral spokesman Tim McNulty said in an email last year. “That is going to change,” he added, noting then-Chief Cameron McLay and his staff “are currently working on separating the language so that policies can be made public, while procedures are kept private.”
Chief McLay left the city last fall. But the manual has not been completed.
Secrecy is not the way to improve police-community relations or build confidence in the police bureau, and the low priority assigned to developing a public version of the manual speaks volumes.
Mr. Peduto should direct his law department and the police bureau to develop a process for putting police policies online.
The public has a right to know how the police bureau operates. Acknowledgment of that ought to be included in the manual.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.