The law should provide justice. But sometimes, despite all appeals to right and reason, the law denies it. That is the latest misfortune to befall the widows and children of 78 miners killed in a 1968 explosion at Consolidation Coal Co.’s No. 9 mine at Farmington, W.Va.
In terms of money and answers, the victims’ families had little with which to carry on. They received a meager $10,000 each from the coal company. Seven widows — their husbands among the 21 miners whose bodies were never recovered — wrangled an additional pittance of 246 acres of vacant land near the mine. Questions about the disaster lingered — festered, really — for decades. Regulators’ inaction was shameful; state officials never filed a report on the incident, though they should have done so, and federal authorities did not get around to filing one until 1989.
In 2008, family members learned about a memo that federal mine inspector Larry Layne had written two years after the disaster, in which he said a coal company electrician told him about the disabling of an alarm that could have alerted the miners to a deadly gas buildup. After former West Virginia University journalism professor Bonnie Stewart published a book about the tragedy, family members and their lawyers identified the late Alex Kovarbasich as the employee who they believed disabled the alarm.
In 2014, they sued the coal company and Kovarbasich’s estate in federal court, later asking the court to add as a defendant Leonard Sacchetti, whom Mr. Layne eventually identified as the electrician he referenced in his report. The families alleged that Mr. Sacchetti helped disable the alarm. Because the information in Mr. Layne’s report was new to them, the families thought they had a strong case.
But the information wasn’t new enough. U.S. District Judge Irene Keeley threw out the suit, ruling that it had to have been filed within two years of the explosion. Even if they learned about the memo in 2008, she noted, the families waited six more years before going to court.
Judge Keeley’s ruling may have been legally correct, but it only underscores the adage that justice delayed is justice denied. The regulatory and legal systems have failed the miners’ families at every turn. But there is still time to do something about that. West Virginia and federal authorities should re-investigate the Farmington tragedy with the aim of giving the miners’ families the answers owed them for most of a lifetime.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.