In recent weeks, members of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board have expressed discomfort with the number of pregnant women incarcerated there. Now, a federal lawsuit alleges that pregnant inmates have been placed in solitary confinement for minor infractions of jail rules.

County officials were alerted a couple of weeks ago to complaints about the use of solitary confinement for pregnant inmates, and jail officials took steps to minimize the practice before the suit was filed. Still, the suit underscores the need to find alternative placements for nonviolent offenders and pregnant inmates whenever possible. Incarceration should be reserved for those  most deserving of it and who are physically able to do the time.

In the suit, filed with the aid of civil rights advocates, five women allege they were placed in solitary confinement for as long as 22 days while pregnant. They claim their infractions were as minor as having too many pairs of shoes, and one of their attorneys, Bret Grote, said the women were not even in the jail for crimes of violence.

The jail should treat inmates with as much care as possible, but the broader issue is that the lockup must accept whatever offenders the courts send its way. Judges and county officials should explore an increased use of alternative placements, as recommended in a recent University of Pittsburgh report and in keeping with Oversight Board members’ concerns about the housing of pregnant inmates. Alternative placements are less expensive for taxpayers and pose less liability to the county.

Meet the Editorial Board.