The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has some explaining to do after a series of stories by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Sean D. Hamill raised troubling questions about the agency’s handling of an investigation into an outbreak of Legionnaires’ disease at the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System.
In the wake of those stories, U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, a Democrat, and U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, have called for inquiries into the CDC’s conduct. The six veterans who died from the outbreak, the 16 seriously sickened by it and all Americans who use VA facilities or rely on the CDC’s expertise deserve the answers that additional scrutiny may bring.
Above all else, the CDC should strive to keep Americans safe, using the best-available research and scientific practices. However, Mr. Hamill’s stories show that some CDC officials seemed less interested in getting to the bottom of the 2011-12 Legionnaires’ disease outbreak than in using the tragedy to discredit a copper-silver water disinfection method they opposed and in undermining two former VA researchers — Victor Yu and Janet Stout — who championed it.
In one of hundreds of emails that Mr. Hamill obtained through a Freedom of Information Act process that took 3½ years — something else that reflects poorly on the CDC — one official noted that Dr. Yu and Ms. Stout had worked at the Oakland hospital where the outbreak occurred and asserted that “doing this investigation will have a bit of poetic justice to it.” There is nothing “poetic” about the deaths of six men who served their country, and how dare someone responsible for the nation’s health take so cavalier an attitude about a disease outbreak?
The CDC approached the investigation with a bias against the copper-silver disinfection method the hospital used to protect its water against Legionnaires’ disease and pushed the hospital to switch to the chlorine disinfection system it preferred. In a 2015 article about the outbreak in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases, the CDC said copper-silver disinfection was ineffective in preventing the disease — even though the Oakland hospital had used it successfully for decades before the outbreak. Other hospitals used it successfully, too. The CDC’s question should have been, why did the Oakland hospital’s system fail in 2011?
The agency didn’t ask that question, but others did. In 2013, the VA’s inspector general blamed inadequate maintenance of the system, not the system itself. That jibed with the accounts of VA workers, who told the Post-Gazette that oversight of the system slipped after the forced departure in 2006 of Dr. Yu and Ms. Stout, who had disagreements not only with the CDC but with VA officials.
In the journal article, the CDC said tests showed that copper-silver in the hospital’s water system had failed to affect the viability of Legionella, the bacteria causing the disease, “within” 24 hours. Left out was the finding that the disinfectant showed results “at” the 24-hour mark. Such nuance is the domain of politicians, not scientists.
The CDC emails obtained by Mr. Hamill show great animosity toward Dr. Yu and Ms. Stout. That is not appropriate, either. Researchers should challenge each other’s findings in a spirit of collegiality, understanding that better science is the shared goal.
So far, the CDC has added insult to injury, refusing to address Mr. Hamill’s questions or make personnel involved in the Legionnaires’ investigation available for interviews. CDC spokeswoman Kristen Nordlund said the agency stands by its work and has nothing more to say. Sorry, CDC. Hunkering down won’t make this go away.
Mr. Casey and Mr. Murphy should put CDC officials on the hot seat and force them to explain themselves. When personal animus becomes so prominent an issue in the investigation of a disease outbreak, the agency’s overall culture must be called into question. A strong disinfectant may be needed here, too.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.