The fall of Aleppo in Syria to government troops, Russian and other assorted forces does not spell the end of that country’s conflict, although it was an important military and symbolic victory for President Bashar Assad and his cohorts.
Aleppo was the core of the apple of the rebellion and its surviving or succumbing to the long, bloody siege represented a critical point in the now six-year-long Syrian war. Given the extent of foreign involvement in the struggle, it can’t be called a civil war. Some external forces were players. These included Russia, the United States, Lebanese Hezbollah, Israel, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Turkey and the Kurds, whether one wants to count them according to where they live or their ethnicity.
The Syrian war is not over, in the sense that rational government has not been restored to at least half of the country. The various armed rebel elements still exist, in spite of the defeat in Aleppo, and control Idlib and other pieces of the former Syria. In other words, there is no reason to expect during at least the next decade that a coherent government will rule over what was pre-war Syria. Anti-Assad-government Kurds have been greatly strengthened in Syria, including by U.S. military assistance to them, and will continue to seek to combine with the Kurds in Iran, Iraq and Turkey to pursue their goal of an independent Kurdistan.
The U.S. policy of the administration of President Barack Obama will continue to be criticized from different angles for the Syrian mess. There are bright spots and dark spots. The brightest is that he did not let the United States be dragged into — except slightly — another serious war in the Middle East. There are enough of those already — Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Somalia and Yemen — without adding Syria to America’s commitments in money and personnel to now-pointless scraps.
Another point of light was the seemingly tireless efforts of Secretary of State John F. Kerry to work with Soviet Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and other parties to bring an end to the conflict.
On the dark side of Mr. Obama’s policy was its wavering between vague involvement and sometime proximity to indifference. The United States helped some rebels a little. Mr. Obama said Assad had to go, but for the rebels, it was a little like a father promising his daughter a unicorn for Christmas. Despite some of the Islamic State’s elements in Aleppo having been defeated, the organization as a whole remains alive, if not well. It just took back historic Palmyra in Syria and shows few signs of collapse in Mosul, Iraq.
The real loser in the whole affair so far is the integrity of the Syrian state. Humankind also has suffered with the irreparable damage to Aleppo, Palmyra and other ancient sites in Syria, literally part of the cradle of Western civilization. And we have to ask, to what end?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.