The city has been more than patient with the Pittsburgh Penguins, who continue to postpone redevelopment of the 28-acre publicly owned Civic Arena site. While a project of such scale is indisputably complicated, and some delays are to be expected, Mayor Bill Peduto had it right in May when he said, “We’re now nine years in. We should be seeing development.”

The Penguins —  awarded redevelopment rights in 2007, as Mr. Peduto referenced — have purchased multiple six-month timeline extensions with development credits from the deal to build the PPG Paints Arena. The Pens remain within the terms of the option agreement, which permits as many as four extensions on various components of the mixed-use project before the team potentially faces loss of its redevelopment rights.

However, frustration is mounting because the project is larger than the Penguins. It’s about the city’s vitality and about bringing prosperity to the Lower Hill District, a neighborhood cut off from Downtown to make way for the Civic Arena in the late 1950s.

In May, Mr. Peduto said he intended to hold the team to an Oct. 21 deadline for starting the first phase of a 1,200-unit residential component. Instead, the date came and went with the Pens buying another extension. The team raised concerns about site contamination — an issue Mr. Peduto seven months ago called “no reason” for delaying the project — and the URA voted Thursday for more environmental testing.

Advertise with us

Despite Mr. Peduto’s criticism in the spring, his development chief, Kevin Acklin, last week vouched for the team’s “commitment ... to advance development.” A new critic emerged, however. URA board member Jim Ferlo, a former state senator and city councilman, called for the agency to “pull the plug on the Penguins” and find a way to take back the development rights now.

Besides site contamination, the Penguins have cited a financing gap and U.S. Steel’s withdrawal as a tenant as reasons for postponing work. In response to criticism about the delays, the team cited what it has done, such as working to find developers, negotiating a benefits agreement with Hill leaders and investing $5 million so far.

Still, the delays raise questions about the Penguins’ capacity to deliver. As Mr. Peduto said in May, “It’s time to get moving.”

Meet the Editorial Board.