The tragic deaths of three innocent people during a police chase on Thanksgiving compel local police departments to take two important steps: Revisit their policies on pursuits to make sure they reflect the profession’s best practices and explore the tools available to reduce the number of chases.
Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said Tuesday that a North Versailles police officer erred in pursuing Demetrius Coleman because his offenses — a traffic stop that led to the discovery that he was wanted on a felony drug-related warrant — didn’t dictate so elevated a response. While a “violent felony” may necessitate a chase, he said, more minor crimes do not.
Coleman took off during the traffic stop and reached 100 mph or so during an attempted getaway that lasted less than a minute, covered less than 2 miles and ended when he struck a vehicle at the intersection of Routes 30 and 48 in North Versailles. Killed were the occupants of that vehicle, David Lee Bianco; his fiancee, Kaylie Meininger; and their daughter, Annika, 2. They were on their way to a relative’s home for Thanksgiving dinner. Also injured were three women in another vehicle and Coleman.
Mr. Zappala said the pursuit of Coleman was not appropriate under standards promulgated by the Allegheny County Chiefs of Police Association. However, he does not anticipate charges against Norman Locke, the North Versailles officer who saw Coleman fleeing and decided to give chase. Municipal police departments should review their policies on pursuits, update those that are out of step with professional best practices and ensure that officers understand their responsibilities. Mr. Zappala advised departments to begin using “Stop Sticks” — tire-deflation devices placed under the wheels during traffic stops — and suggested paying for them through his office.
But departments also should explore other tools that can be used to curtail chases or lessen the need for them. Nearly 100 police agencies nationwide — including the sheriff’s office in Lucas County, Ohio, where Toledo is located — have embraced a technology called StarChase, which works like this: A compressed-air launcher behind the patrol car’s grille files a GPS-enabled “tag” that adheres to a fleeing vehicle. About the size of a can of V8, the tag may be launched when an officer is inside the patrol car or, with a key fob controller, when the officer is outside of it. The key fob is useful because suspects often make a break for it when officers are walking toward or away from them.
With GPS tracking, officers can back off, calm down and plan to arrest the suspect at a safer time, said StarChase inventor Trevor Fischbach. “When the tag hits the back of the vehicle, everything changes. You can hear it in the dispatchers’ recordings. You can hear it in the officers’ voices.” It costs $3,000 to $5,000 to install StarChase on each patrol car, and there are more modest recurring fees after that. Departments should consider seeking federal grants or using drug forfeiture proceeds to cover the costs.
Read More
On average, more than 360 officer and civilian deaths occur each year during pursuits, according to data on the StarChase website. Fewer pursuits not only would save lives but would also reduce civilian injuries and property damages that expose police departments to civil liability. There are other considerations, too, such as whether officers are more likely to use excessive force when arrests occur after adrenaline-pumping pursuits.
Lucas County has installed StarChase on five patrol cars but so far hasn’t used the technology in the field, Lt. Matt Luettke said. The department hopes to buy more of the devices, but cost is one issue and deployment considerations — extreme weather may affect performance, Lt. Luettke said — are another. Still, Lt. Luettke is right to call StarChase a “great step” in managing pursuits, and local departments would be smart to consider it.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.