Here’s further proof that human decency can cut across political camps. U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy of Upper St. Clair, a solid Republican by any measure, is making common cause with Hollywood actors, some of the more liberal members of American society. Their shared concern: an inhumane “Dr. Phil” program on Shelley Duvall, an esteemed actor who is suffering from an untreated mental illness.
“From Hollywood Star to Near Isolation: Helping ‘The Shining’s’ Shelley Duvall” was the title of the Nov. 18 broadcast, which came under fire from the moment its promo was released several days earlier. Phil McGraw, the Texas psychologist turned TV phenom, showed Ms. Duvall, 67, veering between delusional statements and clear calls for help. The program took her to a treatment center, but she declined treatment. The spectacle has been denounced by scores of fellow actors, from Mia Farrow to Ron Perlman.
Mr. Murphy last week said he was “astounded that this was broadcast under the banner of entertainment. It reflects a woman in need of psychiatric medical care who lacked the basic executive functioning to understand the implications of her ‘consent’ ” to be interviewed. Mr. Murphy is well qualified to speak to the subject. The only practicing psychologist in Congress, he has been pushing an important mental health bill since the Sandy Hook shootings in 2012. The Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act passed the House in July, and the Senate is working on its own version of the bill.
People with mental illness do have a right to live their lives as they see fit, and that would include giving TV interviews. They have important stories to share, and many will talk about their mental illnesses as a way to spread understanding of the subject (or any subject important to them). Pittsburgh Mercy Health System recently convened a group of clients willing to speak with the media about mental health issues. It is not wrong to run stories on people with mental illness, even if they are manifesting symptoms of their illnesses.
The problem is that Mr. McGraw’s program (a glitzy production during the sweeps rating period) seemed designed to make viewers gawk at Ms. Duvall’s mental illness. While that is bad treatment of a fragile person, it also perpetuates the stigma around mental illness, and that is the greater sin here.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.