A report released Wednesday calls out Allegheny County law enforcement officials and the court system for putting people in jail when alternatives would better serve the defendants and the taxpayers. Too bad it came out after James Marasco died of undetermined causes in the county jail while serving a 10-day sentence for loitering.

The report, by the University of Pittsburgh Institute of Politics, indicated the jail’s population had swelled to 2,200 despite falling crime rates. Many are locked up while awaiting disposition of their cases; 81 percent of inmates in the county jail are not serving sentences, compared with a national average of 62 percent. Only 19 percent of county inmates have been charged with violent crimes; the rest are there for drugs or the kind of lower-level crimes that landed Mr. Marasco behind bars.

Moreover, as many as 75 percent of inmates have mental illness, substance abuse problems or both. Mr. Marasco had mental illness and used drugs. Mental illness may be the underlying factor in a person’s crimes and should be taken into account before incarceration. The primary purpose of jail is correction, not treatment. It’s unlikely that a person’s mental illness will improve in jail. The illness is likely to worsen, and that is why mentally ill inmates often incur more disciplinary infractions and serve longer sentences than healthy peers.

None of this should be new information to county law enforcement or the court system. For years, county Judge John Zottola has been a steadfast advocate of so-called “problem-solving” courts, such as those set up to meet the special needs of veterans and the mentally ill. These courts emphasize treatment as much as correction and often try to meet defendants’ housing and social-service needs. Judge Zottola once presided over the county’s mental health court. Today, it is overseen by Judge Beth Lazzara, who has brought compassion and deep understanding to the work.

Advertise with us

Yet, as the Institute of Politics report and Mr. Marasco’s death indicate, an increased awareness of alternative sentencing, especially for people with mental illness, is sorely needed. In August, Mr. Marasco appeared before District Judge Thomas Torkowski on a summary count of loitering in Homestead. The judge later said he was unaware of Mr. Marasco’s mental illness. But that question should be routinely asked, especially in low-level cases that could signal a deeper problem.

Mr. Marasco was a registered sex offender. Judge Torkowski told the Post-Gazette’s Rich Lord that he doesn’t usually sentence people to jail for summary offenses but noted that Mr. Marasco had received a number of warnings and was loitering near a bus stop often used by kids. He said people sentenced to jail for summary offenses usually appeal, and he expected Mr. Marasco to do that, too. However, it is wrong to assume that poor, unsophisticated defendants will understand their rights.

Mr. Marasco had found stable housing at Cleft of the Rock Ministries, a Munhall boarding home that takes in men with mental illness and those with records of sex offenses. He should have been allowed to keep staying there. His death drives home the point that jail for minor offenses can disrupt an equilibrium troubled offenders worked hard to achieve.

The Institute of Politics report is an opportunity for local police departments, judges and county officials to rethink incarceration policies and the resources devoted to mental health services. Judge Lazzara’s courtroom would be a great place to find inspiration. The report indicated that more focused use of the jail could save millions of tax dollars. Enhancing or saving lives would be pretty nice, too.

Meet the Editorial Board.