All Americans can agree on this point: The end of the most divisive campaign season in modern history will come as blessed relief.

In the presidential race, the Post-Gazette offered guidance for undecided voters, identifying a range of issues and, in most categories, making a recommendation. We published traditional endorsements in contests statewide and local. Here is a recap:

U.S. Senate

There’s much to admire in Democratic challenger Katie McGinty, who has served as a state and national policymaker without holding elected office. But in his first term, Sen. Pat Toomey has fit the familiar mold of a Pennsylvania Republican senator willing to reach across the aisle on certain issues, most notably background checks for gun sales. Moderate in tone, he has built a good relationship with Sen. Bob Casey, a Democrat. In these highly partisan times, Pennsylvanians are well-served by having members of each major party in the Senate.

Advertise with us

U.S. Congress: 14th District

Rep. Mike Doyle is the definition of “longtime incumbent,” with 22 years in office, serving a solidly Democratic district rooted in Pittsburgh. He has proven to be an effective advocate for the region, comfortable working behind the scenes and securing funding for initiatives (from robotics to infrastructure improvements) that develop over multiple terms. His Republican challenger, Lenny McAllister, 44, has smarts, a personal success story and telegenic appeal. Too easily branded a novelty for holding politically conservative positions as an African-American politician, Mr. McAllister has real potential for public service in Pennsylvania, but has not been able to make an impact this year.

U.S. Congress: 12th District

Democratic challenger Erin McClelland is making her second run against Rep. Keith Rothfus, a two-term Republican in a seat that takes in Beaver County and parts of Allegheny, Cambria, Lawrence, Somerset and Westmoreland. A health-care professional, she has earned our support again for her keen grasp of a range of issues and an undeniable enthusiasm for the job. Mr. Rothfus, lawyerly and low-key, has highlighted his efforts to make government more accountable, and he’s supported needed reforms to veterans health care. But Ms. McClelland would be a worthy successor, likely to combine old-school constituent service with forward-thinking policymaking.

State Attorney General

Advertise with us

There’s bipartisan agreement: The Attorney General’s Office needs a restorative leader after the debacle of Kathleen Kane’s reign, which led to her jail sentence for perjury. The two candidates are highly qualified, but with different skill sets, and we give the nod to Republican John Rafferty Jr., a veteran state senator with solid ties to the law enforcement community. Democrat Josh Shapiro, 43, a former state legislator and a current Montgomery County commissioner, sees an expansive role for the office, which he imagines as the equivalent of the state’s “largest public-interest law firm.” Mr. Rafferty, at 63, pledges to make the AG’s office his last hurrah in public service, and his straightforward approach seems the better bet this year.

State Treasurer

The Treasurer’s Office also has the whiff of criminality to extinguish, as the last elected treasurer, Rob McCord, resigned in early 2015 before pleading guilty to extortion charges. Democrat Joe Torsella is the clear favorite for the position, with a wealth of relevant experience. Most recently a U.S. ambassador to the United Nations for management and reform, he is committed to transparency and fiscal responsibility. Republican Otto Voit has held numerous finance-related posts in the private sector and has notable experience with fiscal matters of school boards. But Mr. Torsella possesses a deeper knowledge of government and a record of having pushed multiple bureaucracies toward improved performance.

State Auditor General

Democrat Eugene DePasquale, a Pittsburgh native living in York, is finishing his first term as auditor general, and we see every reason to give him another. He has cast a wide net, finding wasted money and inefficiencies across the spectrum of state agencies, plus school districts, municipal pension plans and other entities. Republican challenger John Brown, the Northampton County executive, touts his private sector work improving unprofitable companies. But given the impressive work of Mr. DePasquale so far, voters should let him stay on the job.

Advertise with us

State Legislature

The debate about gerrymandered districts creating safe seats for incumbents will continue in another venue. For now, we are faced with five sitting Republican legislators whose Democratic opponents are not compelling competition. In each case, the first-time candidates are fine people who earnestly want to serve in office; as challenger Andrew Zahalsky told us, “I’m the candidate that everyone says they want.” Someday they might prevail, but not this election cycle. We have therefore endorsed Rep. Jason Ortitay over Joe Szpara in the 46th, Sen. Guy Reschenthaler over Ed Eichenlaub in the 37th, state House Speaker Mike Turzai over John Craig Hammond in the 28th, Rep. Rick Saccone over Peter Kobylinski in the 39th, and Rep. John Maher over Dr. Zahalsky in the 40th, even though we admire the oncologist’s catchy slogan that he is “The Cure for the Common Politician.”

Ballot question on raising retirement age for judges

In a word: No.

Beware the slippery language on the ballot question, which asks: “Shall the Pennsylvania Constitution be amended to require that justices of the Supreme Court, judges and magisterial district judges be retired on the last day of the calendar year in which they attain the age of 75 years?” You might not know that the existing retirement age is 70. The amendment seeks to extend a perfectly reasonable retirement age, not establish one for the first time. Sure, lifespans are longer these days, and some judges have wisdom to spare. But let judges work with a cutoff date of three score and 10. They can make a contribution to society off the bench, too.