When Congress created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, it put control of the agency in the hands of a single, nearly unaccountable director. Richard Cordray, a seasoned Democratic politician from Ohio, became that director. Now a federal appeals court has declared the CFPB, as constituted, unconstitutional and given the president direct control over it.

The court’s decision, if upheld, will be historically important. The case should also raise the question of whether too much power is being vested in bureaucrats whose power is unchecked, either by the president or by another branch of government.

According to the U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Columbia, the CFPB’s authority extends from credit cards to student loans and mortgages. Within this vast, important field, and subject to legal limits, the director, all by himself, makes rules, decides whom to accuse of violating them and decides what sanctions to impose if they’re found in violation.

As the court emphasized, the Constitution’s framers empowered officials to restrain one another — checks and balances. There was no check on the CFPB.

Advertise with us

Independent agencies, which the president cannot control, have traditionally been led by multimember panels that must form majorities to issue opinions and take action. A single member of a federal commission, acting alone, has very little power. And the need for a majority can both force coalition building and prevent an agency from going to extremes. Members who are not convinced by the majority may be able to get the attention of Congress or the public by issuing dissenting opinions.

A one-man commission is a prescription for abuse. One man does not have to debate himself. He has no need to build consensus or convince others. Imagine the Federal Trade Commission or the Federal Communications Commission with one, and only one, commissioner.

The case before the court illustrated the danger of a rule by one man without any checks. Mr. Cordray, according to the court, took an activity formerly declared legal (by a less powerful federal entity), declared that it was illegal and ordered a mortgage company to fork over profits it made on deals it signed before the CFPB changed the rules. That, the court said, violated the right to due process.

If you can change the law, bring the case, decide the case and even make what someone did illegal after he did it, you can impose sanctions on anyone under your jurisdiction, almost no matter what he does. In administrative actions, of course, the sanctions aren’t criminal. But they can cause huge financial penalties.

The court could have restrained that particular action without questioning the structure of the CFPB. But that’s not what it did. The court said the structure itself was unconstitutional.

Advertise with us

Because it concluded that an independent agency can’t be headed by a single individual, the D.C. Circuit declared the CFPB properly an executive agency — an agency whose director reports to the president, who can remove him at any time.

The agency may now appeal, and it may prevail.

Meet the Editorial Board.