Last month, 12 of 15 Cornell High School cheerleaders kneeled during the national anthem at a home game. It was meant to bring attention to the issue of police violence against unarmed citizens — especially those of color. Judging by the hundreds of complaints that flooded the school superintendent’s office, it was not well received in Coraopolis.

A video of the Sept. 30 incident on social media is making the community nervous and angry. The video accuses Cornell School District superintendent Aaron Thomas of knowing of the protest in advance and inviting local veterans to serve as color guard so they would be directly confronted by the kneeling cheerleaders. Mr. Thomas denies this, but the theory has taken on a life of its own, thanks to the video. An estimated 600 threatening calls and emails from across the country have been generated by the video so far.

The underlying assumption of those complaining about the cheerleaders is that they have a duty to be “patriotic.” Dissent is not supposed to be an option for those tasked with keeping the football team’s morale up during game season.

By protesting, the cheerleaders have become fellow travelers of San Francisco 49ers player Colin Kaepernick. His protest against police violence and the national anthem began in August and has generated a firestorm of controversy in conservative media. Veterans have voiced support for Mr. Kaepernick because they understand that his right to dissent is what they fought to guarantee.

Advertise with us

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg considers the practice of kneeling during the national anthem “dumb” and “ineffective” but believes it is a protected form of speech. The students at Cornell High School are on solid constitutional ground no matter how many angry calls and emails their protest generates. In the whole history of America, there has never been a convenient time or place for social protest. That’s never going to change.

Meet the Editorial Board.