A new Brookings Institution report raises questions about the long controversial practice of publicly subsidizing stadiums for professional sports teams. But the findings amount to little more than Monday morning quarterbacking.
The study showed that the federal government gave up about $3.7 billion in revenue over the past 16 years because of tax-exempt bonds that municipal governments issued to help finance 36 professional sports stadiums nationwide. That includes $44 million in federal revenue sacrificed for the construction of Heinz Field, another $44 million for PNC Park and $65 million for Consol Energy Center.
The study also pans the stadiums’ trickle-down public benefits. “Decades of academic studies consistently find no discernible positive relationship between sports facilities and local economic development, income growth or job creation,” the Brookings researchers said. “And local benefits aside, there is clearly no economic justification for federal subsidies for sports stadiums.”
We disagree. Professional sports contribute to a city’s brand and give residents an important bond at a time when so many other things — race, income and politics, for example — divide us. Pittsburgh would not be the livable, high-profile, comeback city that it is without sports teams anchoring the North Shore and Lower Hill. Losing them would have been disastrous economically and psychologically.
Every penny cobbled from a variety of sources was needed to build the new venues here. Sure, the federal government could have done a lot of other things with that $3.7 billion. But how much of it would have been wasted on congressional pork or bureaucratic waste? The stadiums are tangible assets that, despite what the Brookings report says, serve as a magnet. The tax-exempt bonds that financed them are available to municipalities for all manner of public projects, all across the country.
The Brookings Institution would perform a better service if it came up with a way to prevent the coddled owners of sports teams from playing cities against each other. An owner who wants a stadium built or renovated only has to threaten to sell or move the team to work fans into a frenzy, set public officials to panicking and draw entreaties from other cities. Congress should have taken steps to prevent this kind of extortion long ago.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.