The Supreme Court handed a major victory to Sen. Rob Portman, a Republican from Ohio, and Sen. Claire McCaskill, a Missouri Democrat, this week in their longtime battle against Backpage.com, an online advertising website and the subject of a child sex trafficking investigation by the Senate. The court upheld a district court decision that the site needs to comply with a subpoena from the Senate’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations to produce financial and operational records.
Although there is no way of knowing what examination of the documents will reveal, it is a testament to the doggedness of the committee’s leaders, Mr. Portman and Ms. McCaskill, who have tried for more than 11 months to pry the records loose, and a serious defeat for Backpage CEO Carl Ferrer.
Mr. Portman has long suspected the website is complicit in the promotion of child prostitution, believing it looks the other way or edits suspicious ads from third parties but allows the ads to remain long enough to generate responses. Backpage contends it uses a multilayered defense to filter out illegal ads. The upcoming documents should reveal exactly how vigilant company executives and managers have been.
ABC’s “Nightline” reported earlier this year that Backpage is responsible for 80 percent of the underage sex trade on the Internet, not because it directly encourages it but because it is easy for third parties to post ads without age verification. The corporate group that owns Backpage is projected to make $173 million this year, much of it from ads for automobiles, jobs and real estate, but a good chunk of the revenue results from sexually oriented advertising.
Mr. Ferrer will no longer be able to cite constitutional protection or hide behind the Communications Decency Act of 1996, a law that absolves websites or online publishers of blame for illegal information posted by third parties. At long last, light may be shed on how pimps conduct their abhorrent business online while staying just outside the reach of the law.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.