When scientists recently announced in the journal Nature that they have tentatively identified a cause of death for Lucy, a fossil of one of humanity’s earliest relatives, it was hailed as the closing of the ultimate cold case.

According to University of Texas-Austin anthropologist John Kappelman and his team, Lucy, a member of the Australopithecus afarensis branch of hominins, fell at least 40 feet to her death feet first from a tree in Ethiopia. The scientists speculate that Lucy shattered one leg on impact and died from multiple internal injuries within minutes. They also believe she was conscious during the fall and tried to absorb the impact by spreading her arms forward when she landed. It didn’t work.

Determining a cause of death 3.18 million years after the fact isn’t easy, but it is possible to go deeper into probing fossils than ever before, thanks to powerful X-ray CT scans, 3D imaging and 3D printing technology. The Texas team made more than 35,000 scans of Lucy’s remains in an attempt to piece the evidence together. Much of Mr. Kappelman’s research revolves around an interpretation of bone fractures that would be consistent with a theory of a great fall.

Still, not every scientist is convinced that the diminutive Lucy, who stood 3 feet tall, died because she ran out of luck navigating the upper branches of a tree one day.

Advertise with us

The contrary theory of Lucy’s death is that the fractures observed in her fossilized bones can be explained as the result of what happens during the fossilization process over millions of years. These dissenting scientists point to the fossilized bones of much larger animals as proof of how common it is since they display the same markings. They argue that all fossils get the same markings after millions of years under shifting ground.

Did Lucy fall, or was she tripped? The questions around Lucy’s death coincide with a much bigger debate about whether Australopithecus was a tree-dwelling species that made excursions to the ground for food or a bipedal creature that walked erect most of the time but continued to live and sleep in trees for safety. Determining the cause of Lucy’s death could illuminate that question.

Ever since Lucy was excavated in 1974, she has been one of the main focal points of debate swirling around human origins. It is only fitting that she continue to tantalize us while defying scientific certainty millions of years after she drew her last breath.

Meet the Editorial Board.