The bad guys are supposed to be in jail or prison. But often, they’re out committing new crimes even after racking up probation or parole violations that should have put them back behind bars. Counties across the nation need to devote more resources to tracking down probation and parole scofflaws and getting them off the streets. Those were the findings of Post-Gazette staff writer Liz Navratil’s yearlong investigation, detailed in her recent series “Missing Fugitives.”
It takes officials in Pima County, Ariz., 91 days, on average, to arrest a person wanted for a probation violation. It takes officials in Hennepin County, Minn., about half that time. Here in Allegheny County, it takes officials an average of 82 days to arrest a county probation or parole violator, making it the sixth slowest of the 17 counties nationwide surveyed for the series.
That is not good at all. In the wake of the series, Allegheny County Sheriff William P. Mullen says he will seek more money for fugitive work. The extra resources are needed partly because deputies assigned to these duties often are pulled for other needs, such as courthouse security. Three county council members already have expressed a willingness to give the sheriff additional money or open a conversation about probation and parole enforcement.
A better division of labor should be one point of discussion, and a better system for tracking fugitives should be another. While sheriff’s deputies are well trained to do the work, it is odd that the county’s Adult Probation Office does not have personnel assigned to fugitive apprehension full time. Hennepin County has a full-time fugitive tracker, who uses social media and other tools to figure out where people are. She passes on the intelligence she gathers to various apprehension teams.
Probation or parole violations can be relatively minor, such as skipping a meeting with a case manager. However, they’re a sign that something is awry — and often something is. The offenders could have gone off their medications, returned to an addiction, encountered a new stressor, fled the jurisdiction or returned to crime. Violations are supposed to trigger arrests so case managers and court officials can evaluate the offenders, if not return them to jail or prison.
When it doesn’t work that way, bad things can happen. Frederick Harris III, a onetime Penn Hills resident charged in the 2014 killing and dismembering of his mother and stepfather, violated his parole nine months before the deaths and could have been arrested at any time. Also in 2014, Kerrese Lawrence killed himself as Pittsburgh police prepared to arrest him in the fatal shooting of his girlfriend weeks before. Lawrence was a probation scofflaw.
Get-tough-on-crime programs of the 1990s expanded the number of people cycling through jails and prisons, but in some ways, the justice system never kept up. Ms. Navratil’s reporting showed that many counties have insufficient data about fugitives; Allegheny County, for example, has no hard data on the number of fugitive warrants on its books. Counties across the country also have poor monitoring systems and fail to communicate with each other. Some fugitives evade capture simply by moving. So much for the long arm of the law.
Counties should develop new tracking, monitoring and arrest protocols with technical and financial help from the state and federal governments. It’s time to keep probation and parole violators from slipping through the cracks in the system.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.