Employees of the state attorney general’s office should know this better than most: Inappropriate behavior can come back to haunt you. It can even cause you public embarrassment.
But then, some lessons must be learned the hard way.
The pornographic email scandal that cost two state Supreme Court justices their jobs now has employees of the attorney general’s office wringing their hands. The union representing narcotics agents went to court to block release of a report naming hundreds of state employees who sent inappropriate emails. It backed off its request for a preliminary injunction, however, after the attorney general’s office indicated it had no immediate plans to disseminate the report. A union attorney hopes to persuade officials to remove agents’ names from the document.
No one connected with this scandal should get a pass. The union attorney contends that some agents work undercover and that naming them could put them in danger. That’s a shameless dodge. He also has said that naming the agents would violate a provision of their contract that prevents management from embarrassing or demeaning them. That’s bunk, too. Agents who sent offensive emails embarrassed and demeaned themselves; they cannot blame management for their poor judgment.
Law enforcement officers like to portray themselves as guardians of the public good. The public good in this case is full disclosure.
The public deserves to know the names of all employees who used state computers or email accounts to send pornographic or otherwise inappropriate emails. Release has been delayed while officials figure out a process for giving employees caught up in the scandal a chance to explain themselves and, perhaps, argue their way out of the report. How much explaining can there be? If you sent an email that flunks the bulletin board test — that is, if the average person would be uncomfortable seeing it posted in a public space — your name goes in the report.
This waltz of evasion is a waste of time. A better idea would be for the attorney general and other state officeholders to reinforce the quaint notion of professional behavior. That means no inappropriate emails, for any reason. Elected officials and department heads also should remind employees of the public’s right to obtain documents, including emails, generated on the taxpayer dime.
Ironically, given the narcotics agents’ angst, the Porngate scandal erupted because of an investigation of email use ordered by former Attorney General Kathleen Kane. She resigned following her conviction last month on perjury charges related to the leaking of grand jury information in another case. Narcotics agents, take note: She paid the price for her misdeeds, too.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.