Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s response to last week’s attempted military coup d’etat has been strong, and is being chastised as an attack on Turkish democracy by some European and American critics. At the same time, it calls out for some understanding.

First, there is a long recent history of Turkish military overthrows of Turkish governments. They have occurred in 1960, 1971 and 1980. Second, last Friday’s attempt took place against a history of grapplings for power between, roughly, secular and Islamic political groupings. The Turkish military sees itself as the guardian of the secular side. The Islamic side, represented by Mr. Erdogan and his AKP party, is currently in power.

Perhaps the best way for Americans to understand what is going on in Turkey is to imagine the American population’s probable reaction to an attempted military coup d’etat here. The constitutional, civilian, democratically elected authorities would come down on the U.S. military like a ton of bricks. There would be arrests of generals, confinements to barracks, and actions against government officials and others who were considered to have supported the coup attempt, just as there have been in Turkey in the past few days.

It gets worse. Some Americans seem concerned that the Turkish government is going to present a long list of charges against Fethullah Gulen, the Islamic cleric in exile in the Poconos region of Eastern Pennsylvania, and demand his extradition to Turkey to face trial. The Erdogan government is worried about him, first, because he is its most prominent political enemy, and, second, because he has a widespread, strong network in the United States and within the Turkish military, which has close ties to the American military. Whether the United States sees Mr. Gulen as a real threat to legitimate rule in Turkey or not, some of the Turks think he and his movement are.

Advertise with us

There is no direct American parallel, but it would be as if Confederate president Jefferson Davis had taken refuge in Mexico and was organizing a “the South will rise again” coup d’etat against the Washington government after the Civil War.

Now, where do we stand? First, the United States continues to have important reasons to maintain good relations with Turkey. There are the wars in Iraq and Syria, on Turkey’s borders. There is Turkey’s role in keeping the flow of migrants into Europe under control. Since World War II, Turkey’s proximity to Russia has been an important factor in U.S., European and Asian regional politics.

On the other hand, it is definitely not to Turkey’s advantage for the Erdogan government to agitate its own opposition further by an extreme reaction to the coup. Kick posteriors, take names and employ whatever measures are necessary to prevent another coup attempt. But don’t get carried away with retribution to the extent of making Turkey’s democratically ruled friends feel obliged to take steps against Mr. Erdogan and his government.

The bottom line is that the United States needs and wants good relations with Turkey. That doesn’t mean Americans have to put up with whatever its government does, but it does mean that we have to try to understand the coup attempt and Turkey’s subsequent position.

Meet the Editorial Board.