For those who suspect that stories of police mistreating black Americans are isolated incidents at best, sensationalized tales serving an ideological agenda at worst, there is a Republican U.S. senator they should listen to: Tim Scott, an African-American who was elected by 68-percent-white South Carolina.

In a speech on the Senate floor last week, Mr. Scott told his stories, including one from a high-ranking soldier. Some Americans, Mr. Scott knows, dismiss men like Eric Garner in New York and Philando Castile in Minnesota for their records. So he offered them stories of more respected members of our society who have been treated with suspicion, and sometimes even contempt.

In just one year, while in elective office, Mr. Scott said, he was stopped seven times. “The vast majority of the time,” he said, “I was pulled over for nothing more than driving a new car in the wrong neighborhood or some other reason just as trivial.”

You have probably heard that before. Now you have heard it from a Republican senator.

Advertise with us

Once, Mr. Scott said, he was followed through multiple turns by a police officer, who eventually stopped him. “I was paying very close attention to the law-enforcement officer who followed me on four turns. Do you really think that somehow I forgot to use my turn signal on that fourth turn? Well, according to him, I did.”

Mr. Scott has a 79 percent score in the current Congress from the conservatives at Heritage Action. That’s higher than a lot of other Republicans. These are not the words of a radical liberal.

Members of Congress get pins to identify them. One day as he was entering a Capitol Hill building, Mr. Scott said, an officer looked at him and said: “The pin, I know. You, I don’t. Show me your ID.” Counting his time in the House, the senator said he had already been on the Hill for five years.

The senator’s brother, who rose to a top enlisted rank in the Army, was pulled over because he was driving a Volvo and that made the officer suspect he had stolen it, the senator said. “I do not know many African-American men who do not have a very similar story to tell.”

One does not endure such things without emotion. “I have ... felt,” said Mr. Scott, “the pressure applied by the scales of justice when they are slanted. I have felt the anger, the frustration, the sadness, and the humiliation that comes with feeling like you’re being targeted for nothing more than being just yourself.” No American should have to feel that.

Advertise with us

What is to be done? Mr. Scott has policy proposals, of course, but he wisely saved them for another speech. This one was for helping people recognize the problem.

When all Americans realize that the problems Mr. Scott described are real, and that they affect people we respect, it will help advance sound policies on policing and profiling.

The problems of race in America are not ultimately policy problems. They cannot be solved by anything we put into the law books. They are social problems, and if they can ever be solved at all, it will be by what we take into our hearts.

Let us — if we have not felt it ourselves or through our friends — take into our hearts the pain of Sen. Tim Scott.

Meet the Editorial Board.