Sometimes a well-meaning apology isn’t enough.

About two weeks ago, Ahmed Al Menhali, a businessman from the United Arab Emirates, was standing in front of a hotel in Avon, Ohio, talking on the phone when several police cars rolled up. Emerging quickly from their squad cars with guns drawn, the officers ordered Mr. Menhali to comply with their instructions, which he did. The incident was captured on one police officer’s body cam.

According to news reports, a 911 call from someone claiming to be the sister of a desk clerk said a man “in full headdress with multiple disposable phones pledging his allegiance to ISIS” had arrived on the premises. The father of the desk clerk also called 911 for help. No wonder the police arrived expecting a confrontation with a terrorist. What they found was a middle-aged man who had come to the United States for medical treatment at the Cleveland Clinic. Mr. Menhali was subjected to 15 minutes of terror as the officers cuffed him before searching his wallet.

When the officers questioned the desk clerk, she said she had never heard Mr. Menhali swear allegiance to ISIS and that her relatives must have misunderstood her. Because an innocent foreign national could have been killed by police, the incident should be fully investigated and charges for a false police report filed, if warranted.

Advertise with us

Marriot International, the owner of the hotel, promised to retrain its staff to be more culturally aware. The city of Avon and its police department also apologized to Mr. Menhali and cleared him of any wrongdoing. Mr. Menhali accepted those apologies but demanded that those who made the false report in the first place be punished. This is more than reasonable.

The United Arab Emirates has warned its nationals visiting the United States not to wear traditional garb in public. These men and women shouldn’t have to alter their dress to make Americans feel more comfortable. Whether out of ignorance or malice, Mr. Menhali was placed in harm’s way. Someone should be held responsible for that.

Meet the Editorial Board.