The Pennsylvania Department of Corrections will never be mistaken for a bureaucracy that puts the health and safety of its inmates above all else. But the treatment of Arthur Johnson, a prisoner at the State Correctional Institution Frackville, would be considered medieval.

As reported in the Post-Gazette last week, Johnson, who is 63, has spent nearly 37 years in what the prison euphemistically calls “restricted release” or “restricted housing.” Most people call it solitary confinement because that’s what it is. Johnson’s lawyer, who is suing to have his client released from nearly four decades of social isolation, calls it cruel and unusual punishment — otherwise known as torture.

Johnson, whose IQ is estimated to max out at around 70, has served more time in solitary confinement than any other prisoner in Pennsylvania history except one. He leaves his 7-by-12 foot cell only three times a week to shower. He is taken to an outdoor caged recreation area the size of his cell five days a week for an hour at a time. Being strip-searched before he’s taken to the recreation area is his only meaningful human contact. His food is served to him through a slot in the door.

This is an abominable way to treat any human being, even one convicted of murder. Johnson, who says his confession was coerced by police, is one of 2,349 prisoners in Pennsylvania currently on the Restricted Release List. He has not been told when or if he’ll ever be integrated back into the prison’s general population. He says the social isolation has already caused him to lose touch with his own humanity.

Advertise with us

If the DOC is to be believed, Johnson has been held for nearly four decades in solitary confinement because of three disciplinary infractions in 25 years. He has lived in nearly a dozen state prisons, always in solitary confinement. This is the kind of Kafkaesque disregard for proportionality and due process that diminishes respect for criminal justice in the United States.

No one will take responsibility for Johnson’s predicament or even explain why it is happening. This goes beyond bureaucratic inertia to society’s acceptance of the slow, inevitable destruction of prisoners’ humanity. If Arthur Johnson spends another day in solitary confinement in Pennsylvania, then the penal system is broken and we must face up to that. This kind of torture deserves more than public indifference.

Meet the Editorial Board.