From their industrial pasts to their new-age economies, Pittsburgh and Cleveland have much in common. Now, the cities are sharing the sports spotlight, too. Less than a week after the Penguins clinched the Stanley Cup, the Cleveland Cavaliers on Sunday won the National Basketball Association Finals, ending a 52-year run there without a professional sports championship of any kind.

Some Pittsburghers, conditioned to dislike Cleveland because of the Steelers-Browns football rivalry, doubtless are sorry to see the drought end. But we should congratulate Cleveland on its success in professional basketball (which Pittsburgh lacks) and other endeavors, just as it should laud us for our accomplishments in professional hockey (which Cleveland lacks) and other fronts.

In truth, the competition between Pittsburgh and Cleveland is something akin to sibling rivalry, the destiny of both cities having been shaped by prodigious water resources, immigration and an industrial might that gave way to stagnation and despair.

Both cities have made comebacks in recent years with story lines that are strikingly similar: Officials have worked for economic revival, though Pittsburgh is further ahead in technology. Casinos have brought a burst of energy to both cities, professionals began moving into condos in the central business districts, old buildings have been repurposed in elegant ways, and Downtown grocery stores opened to great fanfare (Cleveland’s, in a majestic old bank, is a sight for the eyes). The cities have great museums and trendy new restaurants with long waiting lists for tables.

Advertise with us

In a 1998 essay in the Post-Gazette, then-University of Pittsburgh president emeritus Wesley Posvar scoffed at the notion of a rivalry, saying Pittsburgh and Cleveland really were “potential partners” that could achieve great things by leveraging their geographic proximity and other synergies through an “interstate planning process.” He had discussed the issue with a Greek urban planner, Constantine Doxiadis, who believed the cities could form a “megalopolis.”

Though there have been isolated instances of collaboration, grander visions remain unrealized. The time has come to correct this oversight and to forge alliances in government, business and cultural life that bring a new dimension of innovation to the cities’ storied histories. During a meeting with the Post-Gazette editorial board, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzerald noted the cities face similar challenges, such as the fallout from foreign steel dumping, and said there are opportunities to collaborate on trade.

But fear not, football fans. No one is suggesting a merger of football teams.

Meet the Editorial Board.