Media report that the much-heralded Iraqi government offensive, supported by U.S. forces, to retake the town of Fallujah from the Islamic State is underway.

Apart from U.S. and Iraqi government forces, less reported is the important role played in the offensive by Shiite militias and, perhaps most significant of all, Iranian forces, as advisers and combatants.

From the point of view of Americans and U.S. participation in the attack, there are a number of problems. The first is that it has the U.S. intervening on the side of the Shiites in the centuries-old struggle for dominance in the Middle East. The Sunni-Shiite battle need have absolutely nothing to do whatsoever with overall U.S. interests in Iraq and in the region. Fallujah is a Sunni town, which the Shiite regime of Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi and Shiite Iran want to take from the Sunnis.

After that, the same Iraqi government and Iran, joined by the Kurds, will want to take back Iraq’s second city, Mosul. Who holds Fallujah and Mosul doesn’t matter to the United States and is certainly not worth losing American lives or spending more money on 13 years after the pointless Iraq War started. There isn’t even a decent argument that the people of Fallujah, predominantly Sunni, would be better off governed by the Shiite al-Abadi government in Baghdad than by the Sunni IS — an argument used to justify overthrowing Saddam Hussein back in 2003.

Advertise with us

If Washington is concerned about tilting the balance of power in the Middle East away from Iran and toward Saudi Arabia, an Iraqi government and Iranian reconquest of Fallujah cuts entirely the other way.

Finally, what is certain is that the battle for Fallujah — whoever wins — will produce thousands of deaths of innocent civilians and the displacement of many more from their homes. Each time the United States involves itself more deeply in one of these Middle Eastern conflicts, whether it be in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria or Yemen, one result is an increased flow of hard-to-absorb migrants into Europe. There is the misery of those people, and there are the difficulties created for the Europeans by the conflict created for them between their humanitarian and economic concerns.

U.S. participation in the assault on Fallujah does not make sense.

Meet the Editorial Board.