This week’s State Department Office of Inspector General report on email security practices by its leaders is bad news for former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, though not necessarily devastating. Supporters of her bid for the Democratic presidential nomination will not be disillusioned by the OIG report, which they may dismiss as a molehill. But fence-sitters will find their latent suspicions confirmed: that Ms. Clinton thinks rules followed by other people don’t apply to her, if she considers them inconvenient or intrusive, and she’ll try to prevaricate out of a jam when confronted. It’s all too reminiscent of the worst tendencies of the 1990s Clinton administration, where she resembled serving as “co-president” with husband Bill.
The OIG report examined the electronic records management of five secretaries, from Madeleine Albright through John Kerry, who requested the evaluation along with members of Congress. They were prompted by the ongoing criticism of Ms. Clinton for using a private email account, tied to an email server in her home, for communication during her tenure at the State Department from 2009 to 2013.
Despite earlier claims by Ms. Clinton that the State Department tech security wizards were OK with her habits, the OIG “found no evidence that the secretary requested or obtained guidance or approval to conduct official business via a personal email account on her private server.” Worse, her motivation for using the private system was not just for the “convenience” factor she had once cited, but to keep some of her communications outside Freedom of Information Act requests. “I don’t want any risk of the personal being accessible,” she said in 2010 to an aide, who was encouraging her to start using an official State Department email.
Clinton defenders point to the email practices of Colin Powell, the secretary who used a private account for communication when he served from 2001 to 2005. But the official guidelines for email security became more stringent after 2005, and Mr. Powell didn’t receive entreaties to change his practices.
In any case, the State Department report will have only reputational effect on Ms. Clinton. Across town, the FBI is investigating whether criminal activity was involved in the setup of clintonemail.com, and whether authentically highly classified material went hurtling through its insecure digital pathways. An indictment would throw another wrench into the coronation plans.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.