In March, when he appeared in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court on a probation violation and a weapons charge, Youri Whindleton faced the prospect of five to 10 years in prison, followed by the difficulties of readjusting to life in society.
His zealous defense attorney, James A. Wymard, wanted to avoid that fate for a client he believed in and asked Judge Anthony Mariani to “find another way.” No softy by anyone’s definition, Judge Mariani nonetheless took the request to heart. He ordered Mr. Whindleton to read a book by Ben Carson, famous as a neurosurgeon even before he entered the Republican presidential race. Mr. Whindleton was back in court Wednesday to give a report on the 2015 book, “You Have a Brain: A Teen’s Guide to Think Big.” He said it gave him new insights into his life.
This is not the first time a county judge has imposed such a creative sentence. In 1991, Judge Robert Dauer ordered the prolific graffiti vandal Jamie Matthews, known as Serg, to read H.W. Janson’s formidable “History of Art.” He went on to become a high school art teacher.
Creative sentencing occurs around the country, though crowded dockets and a desire for consistent treatment of defendants limit its use, according to Hennepin County (Minn.) District Court Judge Kevin Burke, past president of the American Judges Association. Sentences that shame defendants — forcing them to stand in public with signs acknowledging their guilt, for example — are inappropriate.
But sentences that open defendants eyes’ or point them to a better life should be part and parcel of a justice system that locks up too many people. We would welcome more of it. Judge Burke has sentenced defendants to get library cards and read books. He has sentenced defendants to community service — with the possibility that the charity will provide a letter of recommendation to help them with a job search later on.
Mr. Whindleton, spared prison, must get a job and meet other requirements imposed by the judge who found “another way.” Mr. Whindleton must find his own way. At 21, his life is an open book.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.