Courts are reluctant to overturn convictions, even in the face of new arguments and evidence. It is crucial to get things right the first time, especially in murder cases where defendants face the death penalty.

Last week, the state Superior Court declined to hear an appeal from Michael Robinson, charged with double homicide. His lawyers were seeking to overturn a decision by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jill E. Rangos, denying him information about a computer program the prosecution is using to link his DNA to the case. In light of high-profile cases involving misapplication of forensic evidence, the request was reasonable. Disclosing the information would help to ensure a fair trial.

Mr. Robinson faces the death penalty if convicted of the 2013 shooting deaths of Lawrence Short, 29, of Clairton and Tyrone Coleman, 18, of Duquesne. The Allegheny County district attorney’s office has linked him to the killings with a DNA program developed by Mark Perlin and his Oakland company, Cybergenetics. On its website, the company says the program, TrueAllele, is especially useful in complex cases and more accurate than human interpretation of DNA test results.

Mr. Robinson’s attorneys want access to the source code powering the program so they can make sense of Dr. Perlin’s findings, test them and cross-examine him. But prosecutors opposed the request, calling the information proprietary and the disclosure unnecessary because the results could be validated by other means. Judge Rangos ruled that the information wasn’t material to the defense and that disclosure could hurt the doctor’s business.

Advertise with us

With Superior Court declining to hear an appeal, a question hangs over the case even before a jury has been seated.

Computer programs shrouded in secrecy do not inspire confidence in the justice system. Surely the judge could order release of the source code while including provisions to protect Dr. Perlin’s intellectual property. Cybergenetics says its program is intended to “help ensure that the guilty are convicted and that the innocent are freed.” In Mr. Robinson’s case, that will mean giving defense attorneys a peek behind the curtain. Mr. Robinson’s life is on the line.