There was no joy in Beantown Monday. Thanks to a federal appeals court panel, New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady will serve the four-game suspension imposed on him by the NFL 15 months ago.
Mr. Brady was suspended for being “generally aware” of a plot during the 2015 AFC Championship game to deflate balls the Patriots used on offense. The slightly underinflated pigskins become easier to grip in bad weather.
The Patriots already had a reputation for skirting rules, such as the 2007 case of spying on coaches from other teams, including the Steelers.
“Deflategate” became one of the biggest sports news stories of the year. After an NFL investigation, Mr. Brady was given a four-game suspension and the Patriots were fined $1 million and lost key draft picks.
The team appealed NFL commissioner Roger Goodell’s ruling on the grounds he’d overstepped his authority by changing his reasons for suspending Mr. Brady. A federal district court judge agreed; the suspension was reversed. It was a stinging rebuke of Mr. Goodell’s authority.
The NFL appealed the ruling on the grounds that Mr. Goodell had the right as league commissioner to impose sanctions for violations of the league’s rules. The appeals judges correctly agreed. Mr. Brady and the Patriots can appeal, but it is widely believed that they will lose.
Fans often complain about Mr. Goodell’s judgment, but in this case, he was in the right. No player, even the esteemed Mr. Brady, should be allowed to escape punishment. The integrity of the game depends on everyone playing by the same rules — including the Patriots.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.