Steel dumping, principally by China, has become an American national crisis with particular importance to southwestern Pennsylvania. It requires a decisive U.S. government response on an urgent basis.
The problem is as complex as the world’s steel industry, involving production, consumption and international trade. In recent years America has been home to seven major companies, with 149,000 people employed in mills and 69,000 in foundries. Some 13,500 steelworkers are facing layoffs today. U.S. steel imports last year reached a record 29 percent of U.S. consumption.
There are many reasons for this dilemma. One of these is global steel overcapacity, estimated at 700 million metric tons, seven times U.S. production. China’s government-controlled industry leads the way in excess. Its production climbed from 2000 to 2014 by 540 percent, even as the Chinese economy’s own demand for steel has slumped. China exports its steel at “cooked” prices below fair market value, carrying out what is basically dumping.
American steel companies are thus in a mess. They can’t compete with China’s government-manipulated production and exports. The American economy buys steel primarily for the automotive, construction and energy sectors, which constitute three-quarters of the U.S. demand. These companies quite naturally do not want to pay more for steel just to “buy American,” even if they should. Such action on their part would reduce their global competitiveness. The currently strong U.S. dollar doesn’t help either.
Other world steel producers are also wringing their hands, including the United Kingdom, which has just suffered the blow of Indian-owned Tata Steel putting itself on the market as the British threaten to leave the European Union. The Chinese have promised to lower production, but not until 2020. Their government also is facing paying the price in jobs of cutting production.
For the United States, this is also a strategic question. If the American steel industry is wiped out or much further diminished, where will the steel for our aircraft, missiles, ships and tanks come from? Will China, South Korea or Turkey be the source of our imported steel?
China is currently seeking “market economy” status under the World Trade Organization. The EU and the British support the Chinese request, while the United States does not. Withholding that status until China cuts its steel production, with verified, international measurability, in coordination with the EU and the British, is a means of addressing the problem. How can China be considered a market economy anyway if it doesn’t bridle for political reasons its overproducing steel industry?
Given the importance of this situation for Americans, particularly in this region which hosts — with Illinois, Indiana, Michigan and Ohio — much of what is left of the U.S. steel industry, it is inevitable that voters will make their views known on the subject to the candidates now, in this election year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.