A U.S. Supreme Court decision announced Monday on criteria for electoral districts let stand an important aspect of “one person, one vote” democracy.
The court decision was unanimous, indicating the ability of the court to agree on important constitutional issues in spite of the efforts of the Republican-majority U.S. Senate to hobble it into 4-4 ties by refusing to act on President Barack Obama’s nomination of a ninth justice.
The case in point, brought by two voters in Texas supported by an advocacy group, argued that the population of congressional and state legislative districts for purposes of drawing constituencies should be determined on the basis of the number of eligible voters in them, as opposed to the number of people. In this case, if the Supreme Court had upheld the plaintiffs’ position, this would have acted to the benefit of Texas’ governing Republicans, who are stronger in its rural areas.
Across the country, the Supreme Court’s approval of the procedure would have had different political impacts in different areas, but, in general, it would have supported the efforts of various states to make it more difficult for some people to vote. Methods used to achieve this goal in recent years have included voter identification laws, the imposition of shorter hours at the polls, additional barriers to mail-in voting and more difficult registration procedures — in short, everything but Reconstruction-era poll taxes and demands to require recitations of obscure parts of the Constitution as conditions of voter registration.
The court ruled, in effect, to support the right of nonvoters, including children, to representation in the federal and state legislatures. It did not rule on the continued practice of the states to gerrymander districts, tampering with representation on the basis of urban-rural splits, race, economic status and party preferences. Gerrymandering is undemocratic, making it considerably more difficult to get rid of incumbents, even when it is time for them to go, a poignant subject in this electoral year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.