Mayor Bill Peduto has started what undoubtedly will become a court fight with the city police union over pay for suspended officers, and it’s a fight worth waging.

Under the city’s contract with the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 1, officers on administrative leave or under investigation for wrongdoing are entitled to their regular pay. That’s not in dispute, and it is fair; after all, the maxim of innocent until proven guilty is fundamental.

What is disputed are payments above the officers’ base. Under what the mayor calls a “practice” and the union says is a legal “agreement,” officers who remain on suspension for more than 30 days are entitled to “comparable earnings from the prior calendar year.” That means, if officers earned more from overtime and private duty work, the city would have to pay them that higher sum.

Currently, three officers are benefiting from it, most notably Sgt. Stephen Matakovich. He is suspended and facing criminal charges for punching an intoxicated man during an arrest at Heinz Field.

Advertise with us

In Sgt. Matakovich’s case, the difference between his base and his actual earnings is big money. His earnings last year were seventh-highest in the city — a base of $86,695 plus another $103,949 due to court appearances and extra details.

Paying officers for overtime they aren’t putting in and private details they aren’t working is an abuse of the taxpayers. It is particularly unfair in the case of the private duty, such as providing security at a bar, because businesses pay that tab in the first place, but now the public is being forced to match it.

The FOP says too bad — city officials must live with a deal it says they signed. The mayor’s office says the agreement was intended to apply only in limited circumstances to resolve specific grievances. Assistant city solicitor Wendy Kobee said no such agreement was signed regarding Sgt. Matakovich.

It’s clear that there will be no meeting of the minds on this issue. The mayor is furious, and we’re glad to hear him say he won’t back down. His first obligation is to taxpayers.

Meet the Editorial Board.