President Barack Obama launched on Tuesday his final effort to remove the stain on America represented by operating a prison outside the law at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
The U.S. Naval Station there holds 91 detainees of assorted nationalities, who were captured in the aftermath of 9/11 for having committed suspected violent extremist acts. Yet they have not received their day in court, leading to protracted legal battles and posing recruitment opportunities for Islamic militants in other countries.
Mr. Obama first called for closing the prison before his election in 2008. But Congress has resisted ever since, arguing that some of the prisoners are too dangerous to be brought to the mainland. That position doesn’t stand up, though, since America’s most vicious domestic criminals are held routinely, and securely, in U.S. prisons.
During Mr. Obama’s seven years in the White House, he has reduced Guantanamo’s inmate population from a high of 242. Of the remaining prisoners, 35 have been cleared to return to their countries of origin or elsewhere, if other governments agree. Another 10 have legal proceedings underway or completed. The rest are either facing trial before military commissions or deemed too threatening to let go but have not been charged.
The president’s plan would send the final detainees to a new U.S. facility that could cost $475 million to construct at one of 19 locations in several states. House Speaker Paul Ryan vowed legal action Wednesday if the administration tried to move all detainees to the United States, which he said was forbidden by a law passed last year.
For that reason and others, the closure proposal may be dead. Mr. Obama should be undaunted, however, in continuing to relocate securely more detainees to other countries or charge more of them before military courts.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.