The Albright United Methodist Church in Bloomfield represents a fascinating history — and an important test case for the city’s Historic Review Commission. The commission last week decided to consider the building for historic status, the result of a public campaign to save it from the wrecking ball.

In 2013, the Albright congregation decamped from the 110-year-old structure, a leaky roof among its ailments. The church’s regional body, the Western Pennsylvania Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church, took full control of it. Richard Barton, a lawyer for the conference, said it would take $1 million to restore the building. With development booming in the Baum-Centre corridor, and with another Methodist church to tend literally on the same block, the conference decided to sell it. Ross Development has it under a sales agreement.

Many de-sanctified churches have been successfully transformed into housing, community centers or spirited dining establishments. Ross Development sees retail as the best use for the busy location and new construction as the way to go.

The Friends of Albright has mounted a compelling argument for preserving the building, its 39 stained glass windows a worthy example of the Eclectic period in American architecture. The congregation was a descendant of one of Pittsburgh’s oldest faith groups, the First Evangelical Church. The Friends of Albright, which holds services at another East End venue, is rallying a coalition to raise money and awareness to reuse the structure.

Advertise with us

But supporters should prepare to be disappointed. To start, their standing to bring the case is legally weak; only owners of a religious structure may nominate it for historical protection. The granting of historical status, in any event, would not guarantee the building’s continued existence, as the owners could make a hardship appeal and likely prevail.

Preventing government interference in church affairs is a bedrock American principle. The March 2 Historical Review Commission meeting will be closely watched to see if its members are willing to tamper with an established religious right in the name of a secular good.

Pittsburgh’s churches are a vital part of the cultural landscape. Yet the best way for people to preserve them is to buy them or, better yet, fill their pews and collection plates.

Meet the Editorial Board.