If Sen. Ted Cruz wins his party’s nomination and the November election, will he be able to serve as president of the United States? Some legal minds say yes; others are not so sure.

GOP rival Donald Trump is stirring up the issue. “I hope that’s not going to be a problem for him, but I’ve been hearing a lot about it,” Mr. Trump said last Wednesday.

Mr. Cruz was born in Canada, to an American mother and a Cuban father who had legal resident status in the United States at the time. “We all studied our history lessons. … You are supposed to be born in this country” to be president, Mr. Trump said, inaccurately, when the senator announced his candidacy last March.

The Constitution requires the president to be a “natural-born citizen” of the United States. A child born to a U.S. citizen on foreign soil becomes a citizen at birth — in contrast to “naturalized” citizen, who gains the status after moving here.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trump and others casting doubt on Mr. Cruz’s status are right on one point: The Supreme Court has not ruled on this. But it is not likely to, unless Mr. Cruz is victorious on election night and someone with standing challenges him in court.

The uncertainty surrounding Mr. Cruz’s case is understandable. The opinions of legal scholars may be compelling, but only settled case law or a ruling from the high court would remove all doubt.

Two former U.S. solicitor generals — Paul Clement, who served under President George W. Bush, and Neal Katyal of the first Obama administration — believe the justices would rule in Mr. Cruz’s favor. As they wrote in the Harvard Law Review last year: “The Supreme Court has long recognized that two particularly useful sources in understanding constitutional terms are British common law and enactments of the First Congress. Both confirm that the original meaning of the phrase ‘natural born Citizen’ includes persons born abroad who are citizens from birth based on the citizenship of a parent.”

Skeptics, however, cite this. The Naturalization Act of 1790 provided that “the children of citizens of the United States, that may be born beyond sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as natural born citizens. ...” But the 1795 revision of the Naturalization Act omitted the phrase “natural born” from the sentence. How would today’s judiciary interpret its removal?

Republican primary voters deserve an issues-based campaign without the distraction of constitutional speculation. Even so, until the question becomes settled in court, Mr. Cruz is vulnerable.

Meet the Editorial Board.