Downtown Pittsburgh is growing by leaps and bounds — except for shopping. The closing of Macy’s last year was the poignant end of a department store era, and nothing is on the horizon to replace it.

Retail is essential to a thriving city center. The people guiding the development of Downtown seem to be pursuing a reasonable course: bring back foot traffic and allow business owners to figure out what stores can work.

In Friday’s Post-Gazette, reporter Mark Belko interviewed former Mayor Tom Murphy and Arthur Ziegler, the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks president who firmly opposed the mayor’s grand retail scheme for Downtown in the 1990s. They see eye to eye these days on the need to develop storefronts — which Mr. Ziegler’s organization is doing with exceptional care and taste.

The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, in collaboration with the administration of Mayor Bill Peduto, has chosen to “build off residential growth” to assist the retail sector. It’s the best strategy for now.

Advertise with us

America’s consumer habits in general are undergoing a sea change, from online shopping to shifting values on the accumulation of possessions. Let the city pave its streets and keep them safe, and let the market decide what stores to establish along them.

Meet the Editorial Board.