Commonwealth Court struck a blow for common sense last week by declaring unconstitutional a lifetime ban on employment in nursing homes and other health care facilities for people convicted of certain crimes.

Although the Legislature sought in 1987 to shield a vulnerable population by enacting the Older Adults Protective Services Act, the terms were so broad and inflexible that the law disqualified even applicants whose crimes had been relatively minor offenses committed more than a decade earlier.

The law’s prohibition on employment applied to those who had committed a list of violent crimes, such as rape and murder, but also drug-related offenses, theft and forgery.

The case was brought by five petitioners with old criminal convictions and by Resources for Human Development, a social services nonprofit based in Philadelphia. One of the plaintiffs was a licensed practical nurse who had been barred from working in a health care facility due to a 17-year-old drug conviction.

Advertise with us

Writing for the court, now-President Judge Mary Hannah Leavitt said “the General Assembly may enact laws that limit an individual’s right to pursue a lawful occupation in order to achieve an important government interest, such as protecting school children or older adults from abuse or neglect.” However, the act’s “blanket prohibition lacks fine-tuning because it treats all the enumerated crimes, regardless of their vintage or severity, as the same even though they present very different risks of employment.”

Despite the lifting of the ban, job applicants still must submit to a criminal background check. The state attorney general’s office, which defended the law in court, has not decided whether to appeal.

Pennsylvania officials should forgo a continuation of this legal battle and instead allow the Legislature to devise a better, more specific law — one that keeps recent violent criminals away from the elderly but lets low-level offenders from the distant past seek life-redeeming work.

Meet the Editorial Board.