More than 13 months after the fact, the reality remains hard to grasp: On Nov. 22, 2014, a white police officer in Cleveland fatally shot a 12-year-old African-American boy who was playing alone with a toy gun in a public park. Last week, a grand jury in Cuyahoga County, affirming a request by the county prosecutor, decided not to indict the officer and his partner.
The prosecutor, Timothy McGinty, described the death of Tamir Rice at the hands of Officer Timothy Loehmann as a “perfect storm of human error” and “a tragic confluence of events.” These too-pat characterizations suggest that cosmic forces, rather than conscious bad decisions, were somehow at work. But the errors Mr. McGinty cites began long before the day of the incident and have continued since then.
The killing of Tamir occurred within the context of the Cleveland police department’s recent history. The force has had a reputation — too often well-founded — of being trigger-happy, insular and insensitive to minority citizens. It hired Officer Loehmann despite, and apparently without checking, a personnel record that suggested he was ill-suited to police work, especially the use of firearms.
The day of the fatal shooting, a caller to 911 reported that Tamir was “probably a juvenile” and that his gun was “probably fake.” But the operator and police dispatcher did not convey that information to Officer Loehmann. Following the shooting, the youth went without first aid for long, life-draining minutes.
It took more than a year for the grand jury finally to announce its decision not to bring charges against the officers. During that time, Mr. McGinty commissioned opinions from law-enforcement officials that justified the officers’ use of force. Prosecutors sought to mitigate the killing by asserting that Tamir was big for his age, older than he looked and from a rough neighborhood. Such blame-the-victim talk is offensive.
The city since the killing has agreed to broad institutional changes regarding use of force, but such reforms have come too late for Tamir Rice and his grieving family.
An independent federal review of the Rice case is necessary, as are reforms within the Cleveland police department and city government.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.