Last Tuesday the state’s Court of Judicial Discipline moved expeditiously to suspend state Supreme Court Justice J. Michael Eakin for sending and receiving raunchy, offensive emails.

Although the suspension with pay will continue until his trial before the disciplinary body, Justice Eakin should save Pennsylvania a lot of trouble and embarrassment by stepping down now.

The Republican judge, who built his career in Cumberland County, has been under attack since he was exposed as one of a group of elected officials and state workers who exchanged emails containing photos of nude women, jokes about African-Americans and slurs against religious groups. Some of those involved in the so-called Porngate scandal have lost their jobs; one was a colleague of Mr. Eakin, former Justice Seamus McCaffery.

Despite Justice Eakin’s apology and his declaration that the sexist and racist emails do not reflect his character, he seems to get into more hot water each time he tries to defend himself.

Advertise with us

“Perhaps my demeanor was ‘one of the boys,’ ” he told the Court of Judicial Discipline at his hearing last Monday. “But what I sent was to people who were ‘one of the boys.’ It was in the locker room.”

As if a Supreme Court justice can have one attitude toward women, blacks and people of different faiths while being “one of the boys” and a different attitude while hearing their court cases on the bench.

In papers filed in his defense, Justice Eakin called the emails “male banter” that did not portray the court in a bad light and were not intended to become public. Pennsylvanians can understand why.

The justice also traded emails with a friend in the state attorney general’s office in which the men joked about sleeping with two of the justice’s female staff members during a planned golf outing. The women said at the hearing that they were not bothered by the emails. But the public should be. They deserve better from their Supreme Court justices.

In bringing the case against Justice Eakin, the disciplinary court said the episode “has tainted the Pennsylvania judiciary in the eyes of the public.” The only way to remove that stain is for J. Michael Eakin to remove himself.

Meet the Editorial Board.