City council was irresponsible when it rushed through an ordinance requiring all Pittsburgh employers to provide generous sick-leave benefits. It turns out the action was illegal, too.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James said so when he ruled Monday that the ordinance was “invalid and unenforceable.” Those on council who passed the measure and Mayor Bill Peduto, who signed it, should have known better.

They had been warned by the city Law Department that the sick-leave bill would be vulnerable to a legal challenge because the state Supreme Court ruled in 2009 that municipalities including Pittsburgh cannot regulate businesses “by determining their ‘duties, responsibilities, or requirements.’ ” Judge James cited that ruling in Monday’s decision.

The ordinance would have required any business with 15 or more workers to provide up to 40 hours of paid sick time and those with 14 or fewer workers, up to 24 hours. Setting such work rules for private enterprise is not a job for city officials. They have plenty to do in regulating their own workforce, and if the city chooses to provide paid leave — and the taxpayers go along — so be it. But they hurt their own city by wrapping up private businesses in red tape.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto condemned the ruling, suggesting it reflects negatively on Pittsburgh. If he thinks the ruling will hurt the city’s ability to attract and keep businesses, he’s got it backward.

Firms seeking new locations want a clean, safe, well-maintained home, but they don’t want their business plans undermined by unnecessary layers of regulation — particularly in areas already covered by federal employment law.

The city and its labor allies should forgo appealing Judge James’ decision. Any effort to continue this fight is a waste of time and money.

Meet the Editorial Board.